Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

IF one has some cheap & convenient way to efficiently store MWh-scale quantities of electrical power, then spot-market electricity prices <= 0 are extremely interesting.

Otherwise...not so much. All the electrical infrastructure, from the wind turbines to your electrical meter, still has to be planned, built, and maintained. If there's isn't some perpetual* government subsidy involved, then the cost of doing all that still has to be paid from selling the power, and your ability to "play the market" - without sinking a metric buttload of money into energy storage equipment - is gonna be limited. And the more popular such market-playing becomes, the lower the spot price fluctuations will become.

*Yes, I know that "perpetual" never really lasts in this context.



   MWh-scale quantities of electrical power
Doesn't have to be electrical. I was part of a "demand response" study a decade back where a cold store was provided a prediction of electricity prices. When electricity prices were low or negative, the infrastructure would drive the temperatures to the lowest point to shift future energy consumption to the present. This shift in time is also a form of storage.


Sure, there are cases. Imagine if quick-response aluminum smelters were a thing. But for household electrical use...maybe you could get your well-insulated electrical water heater extra hot, and your freezer extra cold?

But all such cases suffer from the "only if it doesn't get popular" problem.


The only major loads in my home are HVAC, hot water, pool pump, and EVs. Everything else is minor (LED lights, refrigerator, dishwasher, washer and dryer, televisions, network devices). Those major loads can all be orchestrated around the variable cost of power.

(I also have solar on the roof and am a net exporter)


Yes, EVs. No need to build specialized energy storage systems. If we have 10s of millions of EVs (to start with) and eventually 100m+, thats a gigantic energy reservoir that you can dump all excess energy. The best part is some of that energy is used every day, freeing up capacity for tomorrow's free renewable production.

And its distributed, no need to add new transmission lines, available to every grid, today.


>> IF one [...], then spot-market electricity prices <= 0 are extremely interesting.

>> [...] is gonna be limited. And the more popular such [...]

> Yes, EVs [...]

If there there are a zillion EVs, which cleverly charge up when the spot electrical price gets low, then those free-or-negative prices for electricity - which really seem to push people's buttons - will not actually happen.

> No need to build specialized energy storage systems.

I am not aware of either the electrical grid, or most current EV's & their charging hardware, being built to actually do this. A whole lot of specialized stuff will still need to be built.


> If there there are a zillion EVs, which cleverly charge up when the spot electrical price gets low, then those free-or-negative prices for electricity - which really seem to push people's buttons - will not actually happen.

That's desirable, isn't it? You're trying to get to a point where the demand curve matches the supply curve. You want there to an expectation that supply-peak energy is going to be worth something at some point in the future, even if it isn't right now. (Assuming we're doing this in the private sector, of course).

> I am not aware of either the electrical grid, or most current EV's & their charging hardware, being built to actually do this.

I think it's called bidirectional charging.


Right, but what EV supports bi directional charginf today without a $10,000 upgrade?


Personally I reckon DC distribution in the home will catch on at some point. Keep the AC circuit for fridges and cookers, but shift everything else (TVs, computers, lights) on to DC. Not as comphrehensive as adding a DC-to-AC transformer to the system, and you won't be able to sell electricity back to the grid, but the hardware will be cheaper and avoiding the DC-to-AC step will increase efficiency.


That's a terrible safety hazard, DC arcs don't self extinguish, and DC high voltage tends to cause your muscles to hold on to the source.

It's a horribly painful and slow way to die.

--- append

For low power dc loads, running completely separate DC circuits wastes a lot of copper for minimal theoretical benefits.


I'm willing to be convinced, but I'm talking about USB PD or similar at the socket (20V 5A). Would that be so dangerous?


Nissan vehicles often support it. Look up V2G (Vehicle to Grid).

There ate several other models as well, with lots in experimental stages.

But new cars are sold every day. So you don't need everyone to upgrade their vehicle. Deployment will happen automatically - just like USB-C charging on phones & laptops.


> I am not aware of either the electrical grid, or most current EV's & their charging hardware, being built to actually do this. A whole lot of specialized stuff will still need to be built.

Its already done, but not yet widely deployed. Virtual Power Plant. Tesla Electric customers report making as much as $150 a day: https://electrek.co/2023/07/05/tesla-electric-customers-repo...


> Yes, EVs.

No that's a pipe dream. People are recommended to charge at night, when half of renewable energy is missing by definition (no sun is shining) and want to be charged at the morning, not discharged because there was no wind blowing and we needed to keep lights up in local town.


You act like this recommendation is fixed and unchnagable, rather than merely a product of current grid conditions, namely cheap power at night.

In reality, the low price is the recommendation. When day time power becomes cheap, that's when people will charge.


> People are recommended to charge at night

Never saw this recommendation. Some people do, because they have time of use plans which offer completely free and renewable charging or cheaper[1]. And there is no time restriction on charging, cars are parked 22+ hours a day, you can charge anytime except when you drive.

EVs can charge anytime power is negative or close to zero.

1) Your home charging is 100% free from 7:00 p.m. to 1:00 p.m. and 100% renewable all day, every day: https://www.txu.com/electricity-plans/free-ev-miles/electric...


Seems like a key challenge is coordinating all the EV owners to undercharge and then plug in at the needed time.


That's how smart meter work. They can be told when the cheapest time is to charge a vehicle. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/electric-vehicle-smart-charging-...


It doesn't work like that. Car is always plugged in. On your app, you'll have settings to calibrate when to charge. All EV car apps have these settings.


Nothing that some vendor-supplied smarts (in the EV) + a "when do I need my EV" style app couldn't do.


I think it depends on where on Earth you are but at this point, from the point of view of Australia, this seems inevitable due to its necessity in ensuring the maximisation of our natural advantage with sunlight and space when compared with our low population density and lack of water.

The potential for energy arbitrage with Asia is just too great for us to not find a way to achieve it.


Sure, thank you for providing the standard contrarian disclaimer to absolutely every article ever written about renewable energy.

But in a historical lens, that the -UK-, i.e. His Majesty’s Coal Fire, has such abundant wind generation that it can be free every once in a while when The Great Smog was only ~71 years ago is an incredible feat.

* https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Smog_of_London




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: