Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>> IF one [...], then spot-market electricity prices <= 0 are extremely interesting.

>> [...] is gonna be limited. And the more popular such [...]

> Yes, EVs [...]

If there there are a zillion EVs, which cleverly charge up when the spot electrical price gets low, then those free-or-negative prices for electricity - which really seem to push people's buttons - will not actually happen.

> No need to build specialized energy storage systems.

I am not aware of either the electrical grid, or most current EV's & their charging hardware, being built to actually do this. A whole lot of specialized stuff will still need to be built.



> If there there are a zillion EVs, which cleverly charge up when the spot electrical price gets low, then those free-or-negative prices for electricity - which really seem to push people's buttons - will not actually happen.

That's desirable, isn't it? You're trying to get to a point where the demand curve matches the supply curve. You want there to an expectation that supply-peak energy is going to be worth something at some point in the future, even if it isn't right now. (Assuming we're doing this in the private sector, of course).

> I am not aware of either the electrical grid, or most current EV's & their charging hardware, being built to actually do this.

I think it's called bidirectional charging.


Right, but what EV supports bi directional charginf today without a $10,000 upgrade?


Personally I reckon DC distribution in the home will catch on at some point. Keep the AC circuit for fridges and cookers, but shift everything else (TVs, computers, lights) on to DC. Not as comphrehensive as adding a DC-to-AC transformer to the system, and you won't be able to sell electricity back to the grid, but the hardware will be cheaper and avoiding the DC-to-AC step will increase efficiency.


That's a terrible safety hazard, DC arcs don't self extinguish, and DC high voltage tends to cause your muscles to hold on to the source.

It's a horribly painful and slow way to die.

--- append

For low power dc loads, running completely separate DC circuits wastes a lot of copper for minimal theoretical benefits.


I'm willing to be convinced, but I'm talking about USB PD or similar at the socket (20V 5A). Would that be so dangerous?


Nissan vehicles often support it. Look up V2G (Vehicle to Grid).

There ate several other models as well, with lots in experimental stages.

But new cars are sold every day. So you don't need everyone to upgrade their vehicle. Deployment will happen automatically - just like USB-C charging on phones & laptops.


> I am not aware of either the electrical grid, or most current EV's & their charging hardware, being built to actually do this. A whole lot of specialized stuff will still need to be built.

Its already done, but not yet widely deployed. Virtual Power Plant. Tesla Electric customers report making as much as $150 a day: https://electrek.co/2023/07/05/tesla-electric-customers-repo...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: