Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I can tell you why it will: stability. A post here a while back showed CockroachDB just recently started focusing on it where F1 RDBMS and Spanner have been running large workloads reliably at Google for some time now. I have high hopes for CockroachDB but Spanner has a lead here for now. Plus it's available so an ecosystem will start forming.


Keep in mind that once something is accomplished, it's not too long before other companies do the same as well. I see no reason why Azure/AWS can't do the same in next few years. If that gives Google an edge, great! But it won't be for too long.


It's true that copies or improvements can happen.


I'm not sure, but it looks like maybe AWS already has... https://aws.amazon.com/rds/


You can't compare that to Spanner. RDS is a product that helps you manage/scale something like MySQL for you. It would compare to CloudSQL in the Google portfolio.

However, they have their own database engine called Aurora, which is what you actually get when you select MySQL or Postgres for RDS and provides much better throughput and replication behaviour. You can also only have up to 15 Aurora replicas whereas Spanner goes far far beyond that.


Aurora uses a MySQL-compliant API, but non-Aurora MySQL RDS instances are not using Aurora. Those instances are just managed MySQL. Ditto for Postgres (Aurora Postgres is in closed beta)


Generic RDS is just hosted MySQL. A better comparison might be Aurora:

https://aws.amazon.com/rds/aurora/


Still a very far-fetched comparison. Aurora is "just" a read replica system underneath a fairly vanilla MySQL. Better than MySQL, but miles away from the sophistication of Spanner.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: