Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jamesjansson's commentslogin

Yes, this sounds SOOOO bad that it is unbelievable, no self-respecting engineer would do that. Yet Elon did it.


( doesn't even fix it


;


No, don't screw around with people legally. It makes you look dishonest.


He does not look dishonest. He looks like the hero we all deserve. Dial it back a bit, would you?


I think his satire is excellent. Look at how these silly licenses are simultaneously taken very serious and frankly not taken seriously at all. I think he has proven something really quite interesting, and in a pretty amusing way.


How is he screwing around with anyone legally? Has anyone been sued over this? Most of this stuff is unenforceable in any meaningful way. Worst case is really some nasty emails.


Is "latest rules" truly what happens? Or if the law explicitly allows X and also explicitly disallows X, then a person would not be convicted, rendering in this case the latest safeguards in effective?


To say it's complicated is an understatement, there are literally entire books written about it [1]. It's rarely that simple but if one act states X is allowed and another act of the same jurisdiction states the exact opposite (assuming both laws are legally valid), then the most recent law prevails. The principle behind it is that the current parliament/legislature shouldn't be able restrict what future parliaments make laws on (the exception being the Constitution). Otherwise the government of today could make a law thats says 'X is illegal and no law can ever change this'.

[1] https://www.federationpress.com.au/bookstore/book.asp?isbn=9...

[edit: typos]


If the source code is ALREADY released, what is the harm in immediately releasing the fork? Immediate public release of forks IS common practice.


Not really first. I run Tapview, we do micropayments that you can put on your own site, and we go down to 1 cent. Also, I'd say we are definitely not the first.


Well I'm building one right now with my cofounders. We're nearing production and we have recently received a small investment.

https://www.zipsub.com/


Another competitor in this space. Welcome!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: