Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
[flagged] Scientist's Gender Is Switched in Press Coverage (chronicle.com)
20 points by slvv on July 18, 2015 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments



In case anyone reflexively thinks, as I did, "probably making a mountain out of a typo molehill", the author says:

> To be fair, "Kelsey" can be an androgynous name, but female pronouns were used in the original news release, so these had to have been deliberately changed. One of the news organizations that changed my gender had actually interviewed me, in person.

and, heartbreakingly:

> … why does it matter? The women who set the path before I came along had to deal with much more egregious social norms and behaviors. By comparison, these "small" things hardly seem noteworthy. However, even small things add up over time to create an environment that makes it clear when you’re an outsider.


> If you do an image search of the word "scientist," you will likely get a flood of pictures of mostly white males wearing lab coats.

This appears to no longer be the case, at least for me in the US.


I agree, but most of the pictures look like stock photos or clipart. In my opinion, the first genuine photo are #16 and #19 (in my personalized order produced by Google image search, your numbers may vary). Anyway, the apparent genuine photos also have a good variation.

My complain is that most of them use white coats, so they look like Chemistry/Biology/Medical scientific. I never saw a Physics scientific with a white coat.


What should a physicist stock photo / clipart show?

That's probably a useful niche: stock photos and clip art that represent actual science.


Stock photos of real science is hard, it's easier to put someone standing at the side of the equipment they use in the real scientific work.

For experimental physics I like the photos of optical tables ( https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&q=optical+tables+lase... ) and the racks with a lot of electronic equipment ( https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&q=physics+laboratory+... skip the first 10 images). They look like something you may find in a real laboratory.

Theoretical physics is harder, they look like normal people (i.e. mathematicians) until they start to talk about the real word. I prefer to discuss writing in paper, but for a photograph the only sensible solution is to write a bunch of slightly related equations in a blackboard.

(And there are many other science branches. For Geology you may put someone with a bunch of rocks, but I don't know a real geologist so it may be not a representative image.)


Yeah for me at least half were of women


I wish there was a law that all articles had to have an abstract at the beginning.


To be fair, this is a blog post, not an article; and I think that the HN title (which is not the blog post's title) is about as succinct an abstract as you can get. (EDIT: I'm sorry, I'm wrong; it is an article on The Chronicle of Higher Education. I think that my second sentence still stands.)




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: