Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I really don't understand what you're arguing against here.

> Thus slavery in the United States is now illegal, severely increasing the costs and the risks of operating a human trafficking enterprise. That's all that we really can do.<

No, there's quite a lot more we can do. Foreign policy is all about influencing what goes on beyond your own borders.

> I see plenty of things wrong here. Is that $40K USD? Is that $40K USD in today's money or in the value of the dollar in 1850? What does it cost to make a living in Haiti? How far will $100 or $50 US go?

The word "equivalent" in the original article is clearly meant to convey that it's $40k in today's money. (as would even a tiny amount of knowledge of economic history, surely?)

I don't know how far $50 will go on the average Haitian salary, but surely part of his point is that in this case there is a population (visiting American tourists) for whom $50 is disposable income. It was never the case for historic US slavery that the price of a slave was anything less than an investment.

(And slave importation may not be the end goal. Maybe you just want a slave for two weeks while you enjoy your holiday. Is that less reprehensible?)

> Places like India have grown in population since the time of slavery in the United States. I would really like to see numbers based on % of population for these countries rather than raw numbers (and historical percentages for comparison, obviously)

Well, yes, comparative numbers would be interesting. (and I'm fairly sure nobody would be surprised to learn that there is less slavery per head of population than previously - but does that make it any less bad?)

I don't think human misery works on the calculus you're trying to apply. One million people in slavery are going to be fairly unhappy, whether they're embedded in a population of 50 million or 5 billion. If the number of people in slavery is increasing, that's bad, even if it's going down as a percentage.

> Do you really think that any US President is going to wipe out all slavery world-wide within a single term through only foreign policy decisions? Do you even believe that it's possible in the short-term without some sort of war/bloodshed?

Do you really think that's what he's asking for? Do you really think an appropriate alternative is just to shrug your shoulders, put it in historical context and do nothing?

Do you really think that if something can't be fixed immediately, or its fix isn't immediately obvious, we should just not bother thinking about it?



> Foreign policy is all about influencing what goes on beyond your own borders.

How about some specifics?

For example, what military action is acceptable and when?

Is there a conflict between this and the belief that one can't "impose democracy" from outside? (Obama, among others, says that he believes that.)


> No, there's quite a lot more we can do. Foreign policy is all about influencing what goes on beyond your own borders.

My point was that he was acting like the Civil War was a 'war to end slavery world wide' and he almost comes off as surprised that a Civil War years-ago in the US hasn't affected the slave trade on the opposite side of the planet. The point of the Civil War (in terms of slavery) was to abolish the plantations and make the slave trade illegal (i.e. to 'free the slaves').

Abolishing the legal trafficking of slaves is one step in the process, obviously, but a major step nonetheless.

> It was never the case for historic US slavery that the price of a slave was anything less than an investment.

This was mostly due to the cost of trafficking in the slaves. If I go down to Haiti the slaves that I could buy there aren't shipped from the other side of the world. If one wanted to buy a slave in Africa in the early 1800's I'm sure it would have cost you a lot less than right off the slave boats in the colonies. Even shipping a boatload of slaves around the world now would probably cost a lot less than it did then.

I guess what really irks me about this -- and my point -- is that presenting the low-cost of purchasing a slave today comes across as shock-value to get an emotional response. And the response that he seems to be going for is to get people thinking that globally humans have de-valued human life more now than in the past. My argument is that you can't compare the price of a slave in the 1800's to the price of a slave now and use the severe difference in price as proof that the people of the 1800's put a higher-value on human life.

> (and I'm fairly sure nobody would be surprised to learn that there is less slavery per head of population than previously - but does that make it any less bad?)

Doesn't make it any less bad, but it feels very deceptive to use raw numbers like that without presenting relative numbers. It feels like they are trying to get people to reach the wrong conclusions, but with the right intentions.

> I don't think human misery works on the calculus you're trying to apply. One million people in slavery are going to be fairly unhappy, whether they're embedded in a population of 50 million or 5 billion. If the number of people in slavery is increasing, that's bad, even if it's going down as a percentage.

Maybe the problem here is that I'm not mainstream enough to be the intended audience. I feel like I want to see all of the numbers, and when numbers are pushed off to the side, it feels very deceptive to me.

Aside from that, I feel that the best way to measure progress is whether or not the numbers are going down as a percentage. Especially compared to the percentage of population growth. If the number of slaves goes decreases by 2% and the population grows by 1%, I see that as a net win. I also think that it's unrealistic to think that we will ever get the number of slaves down to 0, though I would hope it's possible... even if it has to be on the long-long-term.

> Do you really think that's what he's asking for?

He said: He needs to hear from all of us that the true abolition of slavery needs to be a part of his legacy.

That comes off to me as too positive. That sounds like he thinks President Obama is going to abolish slavery. 'The true abolition of slavery' will not be part of Obama's legacy unless he actually abolishes all slavery.

I'm all for better foreign policy regarding slavery, don't get me wrong, but I thought that this guy's message was too positive. Better US foreign policy regarding slavery is a win as long as 1 slave gains freedom over it, but I daresay that foreign policy alone might not make a dent in world-wide slavery for at least a decade (though I'm really pulling that number out of nowhere; feel free to contradict me).

In general, I'm not disagreeing with the need to combat slavery. I'm disagreeing with some of what this guy is saying because it's coming across as deceptive (even though the intentions may be good) and too overly optimistic (I believe in setting realistic goals).


I feel like I want to see all of the numbers, and when numbers are pushed off to the side, it feels very deceptive to me.

There is definitely some funkiness going on with the numbers here, but I'd point out a few things.

1) In an interview like this, you wouldn't really expect to get the full set of numbers.

2) There is a theory that you need to grossly overstate a problem for anyone to do anything about it. In general, I think this is true, most people don't respond to "half a percent of the world's population is in slavery" even though this is an absurdly high percent (assuming you agree with his definition).

Overall I agree with you that having more numbers would be informative, I just don't think that the lack of numbers in this article is representative of anything.

My argument is that you can't compare the price of a slave in the 1800's to the price of a slave now and use the severe difference in price as proof that the people of the 1800's put a higher-value on human life.

Sure, but the point is that moderately rich people can now go somewhere and acquire slaves and have no need to even treat them so well as to give them a place to live and some minimum amount of food since if you lose one, another one isn't too expensive.


I'm curious about your reactions because I felt a similar sense of unease while reading this article -- feeling that I was being sold something, instead of learning something. I managed to set it aside because I encountered various vestiges of this industry where I live in S.A., and was spurred to look into it a bit.

  That presenting the low-cost of purchasing a slave today
  comes across as shock-value to get an emotional response.
  And the response that he seems to be going for is ...
I'd say that this seems at odds with

  I feel like I want to see all of the numbers, and when 
  numbers are pushed off to the side, it feels .. deceptive
Although, as you mention, it'd be nice to see ALL of the numbers. Still, you could probably suss up your own percentage comparison with wikipedia.

But here he's just presenting a solid, straightforward bit of data: the retail price.

You said that this is (or feels) a bit disingenuous -- giving us data out of context to provoke emotion; NY isn't Haiti; it's hard to get the slaves across borders; slaves were money-making operations in the past and aren't anymore, which is why the price is down.

Incidentally, human slaves ARE still money-making machines, albeit less completely than during the days of slavery. Brothels are the most straightforward example -- in the country I live in (most of the time), prostitution itself is essentially legal; it may be illegal, but the enforcement is all of the regulatory type (stay-classy headline: "Officers Check Douches In Area Prostibulos.")

Despite this, human trafficking is a not-insignificant component of the prostitution industry there. Why?

The economy is getting better. A pretty young teenage girl has way, way more options than selling her body. So the only way to get and keep 'good talent' is, essentially, slavery that starts really young.

Now, in that context, it's clear that the retail price is an important part of the equation. If one of the ways you make money is the sex tourism industry (either globally or regionally), clearly you've figured out how to scale either the movement of your humans or the business of attracting customers to you, and the price of the humans is an important data point; the fact that it's so low, given how much harder smuggling people is than cocaine, is a disheartening problem for those considering where to target disincentives.

  it's coming across as deceptive (even though the intentions may be good)
I think that it may be feel that way, but as the facts seem to be solidly behind (essentially) everything he's saying, I'd ascribe that more to the artificiality that comes from other sources.

Like being asked, over and over again (speaking engagements, book tours, countless one-off interviews like this one), to try and squeeze the impact of an important message through the needle-eye of interview questions of variable quality.


> I'd say that this seems at odds with

Well, to put my thoughts into more clear terms, I felt that presenting the one figure while 'withholding' the others is what made me feel like it was being presented for shock-value.

> Now, in that context, it's clear that the retail price is an important part of the equation. If one of the ways you make money is the sex tourism industry (either globally or regionally), clearly you've figured out how to scale either the movement of your humans or the business of attracting customers to you, and the price of the humans is an important data point; the fact that it's so low, given how much harder smuggling people is than cocaine, is a disheartening problem for those considering where to target disincentives.

1. Don't immediately think that because there is a steady stream of women into brothels as slaves means that they are necessarily being imported. Trafficking in humans is relatively easy (so far as transportation goes), until you have to cross a border/checkpoint.

2. In the context of his Haiti example, he's being slightly deceptive by only quoting the retail price and forgetting to include the hidden fees. Even if he just flew down to Haiti to buy a slave, abuse him/her for a few days and then fly back to New York, the cost of the flights and accomodations are not being quoted there. Sure, if he was a Haitian, he wouldn't have those costs, but how many Haitians have $50 USD to buy a slave? It might make sense if Haiti has a sex-tourism industry, but I've never heard of it. (Of course, I'm not exactly on the 'pulse' of the sex-tourism industry or anything)

> I think that it may be feel that way, but as the facts seem to be solidly behind (essentially) everything he's saying, I'd ascribe that more to the artificiality that comes from other sources.

Like being asked, over and over again (speaking engagements, book tours, countless one-off interviews like this one), to try and squeeze the impact of an important message through the needle-eye of interview questions of variable quality.

If that is the case, I feel he should work harder on his delivery of the message. I know that it might look like I'm tearing him a new one in my comments, but I do feel that his cause is a noble one. I feel that he does have valueable experience, information, anecdotes to bring to the table. I just think that he needs to refine his delivery of the message and his call for action. I could just be getting too picky/OCD over this though.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: