The real crazy bit about Heartbleed was that it was worse than a man-in-the-middle attack. It's a "give an unrelated third party on the side your plaintext" attack, rendering your SSL connection less secure than an encrypted connection.
HN, I'm sorry to have deleted my comment before noticing this reply. For the record it said something about 1) being put at ease by the Cloudflare challenge, suggesting to me no MITM attack was possible, 2) and then bemoaning the fact that the NSA "is the man in the middle"