I didn't think it judgemental but I did find it typical. As an engineer I've always been drawn to "functional" clothes (do the maintain the right temp, can I carry my stuff, do they launder easily) but that is not the 'norm' for a lot of people it seems.
If you look for it you can easily identify how much emphasis people put on their outfit. So our author is somewhat focused on that, and a number of my east coast friends have been trained by social cues what "is" and "is not" acceptable dress, which they follow or don't in equal measure. It is one of the more observable culture differences in the US.
Is Washington DC in the Northeast? Basically folks I have hung out with who are in that nominally urban region defined by New York, Boston, and DC are certainly more aware of appearances than folks in the Portland/San Francisco/San Jose region.
I'm careful not to assign 'caring' or 'not caring' because it is that the attribute of caring is more evenly distributed, its more about awareness for me.
Boston isn't that appearance-conscious, at least as far as clothes go. It's much snobbier about academic pedigree, which books you've read, and how much interesting trivia you can recall.
I'd say that the fashion corridor runs from New York (epicenter) down the eastern seaboard.
Paul Graham's "Messages cities send" piece is a pretty interesting reflection on this:
If you look for it you can easily identify how much emphasis people put on their outfit. So our author is somewhat focused on that, and a number of my east coast friends have been trained by social cues what "is" and "is not" acceptable dress, which they follow or don't in equal measure. It is one of the more observable culture differences in the US.