Does it matter much? Books are digital anyway and every book has a copy of itself somewhere in the world.
It's not like something irreplaceable is being destroyed.
These projects are trying to crawl the whole ISBN space. I know for a fact from my own academic discipline that there are ISBN-issued books containing some useful scholarship that were printed in a print run of as little as 50 or 100 copies, and for various reasons most of those copies are basically lost now to digital-archiving efforts. If someone is destroying a remaining copy before shadow-library scanners can get to it, that is indeed lamentable.
The solution would seem to be not to blame the AI companies for using their property as they wish, but to loosen copyright law so they could release their scanned versions to the public and/or resell their books after scanning them. Or force publishers to print on demand any work they wish to keep the copyrights for.
Why do you think they want to release the scanned version? Having a model trained on exclusive content not available to competitors is a competitive advantage.
Selling the books afterwards would be additional work and not guaranteed to bring any profit or even any significant reimbursement. A company is likely to find simply pulping the books to be the most cost-effective solutions.
I think you are overestimating the amount of people outraged by this, and so overestimating a business's need to placate them. Among popular discontent against AI companies, this is very far down the list.
This has been covered well enough in the press (this HN link is to Forbes, a mass-market content mill). It is no secret. Me, I concluded that one reason for the lack of outrage is probably that the general public is less and less interested in books as a format.
Thank you. Everyone acts like every book gets 20k copies and is endlessly available. Feels like a time to modernize the federal government library and FEDLINK to recieve scans of every destroyed book to ensure these rare copies are not lost in this manner.
if you have familiarity with books, you will know that they are also unofficial repositories. a book may be published, but after purchase it may be annotated, dog eared, and exposed to a work environment, basically imbued with information beyond its original manifest.