I'm making no judgement(s) at all. I'm observing that it was downvoted and flagged and is now dead, which is the judgement of HN collectively, not my own.
If you feel that your comment is flagged in error, please contact hn@ycombinator.com
It may have been a very fine comment in another context, but it appears to not have been a good comment on HN, as determined by HN. What other metric would apply?
Please tell us your qualifications to judge whether my comment was a good one.