Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
That Time America Outlawed Pinball (2016) (history.com)
65 points by cdme 10 months ago | hide | past | favorite | 26 comments



Hard to believe? Possession of a pinball machine is still a first-degree misdemeanor where I live.

https://codes.forchagrin.com/chapters/chapter-715-coin-opera...


I have to wonder if this applies to private collectors. As drafted, it sounds like removing the coin mechanism[0] would be enough to dodge the ban if you just happened to have a pinball machine collection for private use.

Though the idea of police officers raiding someone's pinball machine collection sounds both hilarious and heinously overreaching at the same time.

[0] To be clear, this law probably would apply to freeplay arcades that charge for entry and electronic arcade money systems like Intercard's swipers or the ones that operate on save data cards in Japan.


I'd argue that you don't really need to remove the coin mechs if you set the machines to freeplay. And maybe that you could charge admission to get into an area with machines on freeplay.

I might not be willing to bet my machines on it, though. Although I would be highly amused to be legally declared a nuisance. :D


The law probably only applies if you upset the police or otherwise annoy someone in charge.


Did you put this together? It looks great. The site our village uses to host its village code is an atrocity so I’ve been considering rolling my own unofficial version.


I did, thank you!

Our official code is hosted by American Legal Publishing [1], but it's so bad that I decided to download a copy and try hosting my own.

After I was elected to our village council I started to notice the similarities between legal code and computer code – large amounts of plain text, formatting, and change management.

I ended up using Markdown with some special CSS styling, and the site is generated by Jekyll and hosted on GitHub Pages. BBEdit and regex was a huge help to whip it into shape.

You are welcome to use anything I've done [2]. I would love to see more people doing the same.

[1] https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/chagrinfalls/latest/ov...

[2] https://github.com/briandrum/codes.forchagrin.com


Lots have heard "code is law".

Fewer have noticed "law is code".


The GitHub repo is 404ing. Maybe it's set to be private?


Fixed, thank you.


Haha, yep. Ours is American Legal Publishing, too.


There’s a fairly recent movie [0] that charmingly dramatizes the efforts of New York City activist Roger Sharpe to overturn the city’s ban. It’s aesthetically satisfying and good-humored, and it weaves a fair amount of history into a lighthearted good time.

“Pinball: The Man Who Saved The Game”

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinball:_The_Man_Who_Saved_t...



It shouldn't be surprising. Just take a look at pachinko for the modern day version.


And pinball back then was pretty similar to pachinko, according to the article.

"Before the advent of flippers in 1947, pinball was a considerably different game from what it is today. Except for tipping the machines, players were at the mercy of the random bounce of the ball. Players gambled on games, and operators handed out prizes from free games and gum all the way up to jewelry and chinaware."


Pre flipper machines are straight up designed to be gambling machines; I have a couple in my collection. Most of the articles and coverage conveniently leave out this fact. The effect at the time was the same as it would be today if private businesses could all install one arm bandit slot machines. I personally think it was all handled very poorly, and I love what pinball became from the ordeal, but there was certainly justification against the machines at that time.


Might be surprising to young people who are used to people casually gambling on sports 24/7 using their phone.

Crazy how gambling went from a highly restricted thing to a full blown, anytime, anywhere, no restrictions thing without any federal legislation (that I am aware of).


Those mobile sports gambling apps aren't legal in most states as far as I know. They also block IP addresses outside the legal states.


Check out the pinball museum in Virginia. Amazing.


Also the museum in Alameda CA, which does a good job of walking you through the history of the ban.


Now I'm thinking of Tommy (1975) featuring The Who, where at one point the protagonist--psychosomatically deaf, mute, and blind--has become a pinball-playing phenomenon through his sense of touch alone, facing the reigning "Pinball Wizard" [0] played by Elton John.

Not sure whether pinball was outlawed in the fictional location though.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jL53EUbHazo


for me this url redirects to the home page of https://www.historylatam.com/ which seems to be some kind of ufology and did-the-aliens-build-the-pyramids channel. probably the domain should be banned as malicious content

this is not the kind of content that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity


Unfortunately the official History channel website always redirects you to the Latin American version, preventing people with a Latin American IP address to access any US content.


That's actually what the History Channel airs on cable in the US. It was originally a serious channel that covered history but now shows conspiracy nonsense and shows about pawn shops. It's one of the most infamous examples of network decay along with "Music Television" which now plays crappy reality shows instead of music videos. Before the History Channel became the conspiracy nonsense channel, it was basically the Hitler Channel because talking ad nauseum about World War 2 brought in more ratings than other historical topics.

See https://www.reddit.com/r/television/comments/t6wmv8/when_did... and https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/437715-grassley-mocks-th... for evidence of the channel's current reputation in the US.


I once drew a comic that parodied the History Channel. It involved "Unicorns of the Third Reich".


i believe that up until recent years replay/special features were illegal on machines in new york state as they were believed to be used to signal payouts in gambling settings.


This was a major plot point in Licorice Pizza!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: