Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I will say Microsoft is overly agrees installing Teams. When removing I find three different listing under add/remove programs. The App Store version Microsoft Teams, the Microsoft Teams system installer, and Microsoft Teams.

It then proceeds to try and set the default to auto-launch and request a Microsoft sign in at login.

This is aggressive, annoying and in at least to me comes off as desperate or in the least adwarey.




They also have separate downloads for "Teams for home" and "Teams for work or school" that end up running as different applications.


Those two different versions are being merged into one. There's a beta client version out which has those merged.


> There's a beta client version out which has those merged.

That's good, though temporarily, that means one more possibly simultaneously installed teams :)


Installing the updated beta replaces the Office installed one. I don't know if it's possible to have the old Office installed one and the beta client at the same time.


There's a toggle for it (that requires 365 apps restarted) so it seems like you can, somehow.


It's still just one installation though. Like, in All Programs, there isn't the old Office Teams and the new Office Teams.


Yet when I search for teams in the start menu, I get two entries for "Microsoft Teams (Work or school)". If I click on the one without "new", it'll launch the old one and ask me if I want to go back to the old one or keep using the new one.

https://i.imgur.com/FFn1PWa.png


I imagine one is an old Start Menu folder shortcut that didn't get cleaned up right? Its still the same install.


See the end of my comment: it launches the old app and asks if I want to switch back, it's not a dead link.

https://i.imgur.com/ODn13Ux.png

The link points to an executable that dates from the latest update of the old version a few days back. I've only installed the new one today.

I went investigating a bit, and there are two installations, running from different paths.

https://i.imgur.com/TbBXw3N.png

Actually, the same thing seems to happen with Outlook, if you enable "new outlook".


Weird, I assumed it was just replaced, because my start menu just shows the default Windows one and the new Office installed one.

https://i.imgur.com/UvcWlxH.png


I think you can uninstall the old one but by default just enabling the preview doesn't uninstall it. Or at least, that's the behavior I've seen on my machine (same as vladvasiliu).


Can confirm, I was able to remove the old one, and the new one still works for the time being (didn't reboot yet).

One fun thing I've just noticed: the "new teams" toggle has gone away.

https://i.imgur.com/V9eJBre.png


Oh...so it does get worse.


The funny part is Teams doesn't work half the time anyway.


I use it on Windows, and it's not the best application I've used, but I can't think of many meetings where I was unable to attend...maybe a minute of kill teams + restart. But, I hear it's more flaky on macos.


> can't think of many meetings where I was unable to attend

does this mean you can think of /some/ meetings you were unable to attend? I would assume that "doesn't work half the time" was slightly hyperbolic, and so it seems like your experience is roughly in line with the parent comment despite your response being worded like a rebuttal.

> maybe a minute of kill teams + restart.

lol, okay. so it's basically flawless.


Yes, I'm saying over a couple years I can think of a few times where I had notable trouble. It's not great, but it's not on my top 10 list of troubles. It's also not terribly different from my historical experiences with webex and other similar software. Multi-person video chat tends to find the weak points (slow vpn, using during os updates, etc).

>lol, okay. so it's basically flawless.

I never understand what this kind of snark is meant to do. I didn't say anything like that at all.


just so we're on the same page, you think having to kill and restart while you're in or trying to join a chat or meeting doesn't count as notable trouble, because after all you were able to join eventually?


Comparatively, it our current world of mostly shitty software, occasionally having to restart my meeting software is not something I worry about much. Perhaps you meet more often than I do, so it's of relatively higher importance.


I don't think it matters how often you want to meet. When you do, you should want it to work. We're not talking about a side feature either, this is software for having meetings.

Microsoft is one of the wealthiest companies on this planet with decades upon decades of experience in software. Let's not pretend like their willingness to cut corners wherever they can and compromise on quality, as long as the profits keep coming in, is anything but an affront. Controlling the whole stack should make it easier to do this, but in reality monopolies have the opposite effect because capitalism has these averse incentives baked in. Yet another reason to bring back aggressive antitrust enforcement, i.e. break up big tech.


Teams video/chat calls work really well in my opinion. The problem is everything else


Recently untangled this WTF. So stupid.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: