Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I too would like to suspend thermodynamics, because I have some awesome ideas for perpetual motion machines. I would also like my grilled cheese sandwiches to fly. But you started this discussion by implying Obama was a hypocrite for wanting to vet cabinet-level nominees, and you should concede that you were wrong to do so.


Speaking of intellectual integrity, I never said anything implying Obama should not vet candidates. I disagree with one specific part of the vetting process, that candidates should be required to out themselves for having ever entertained any "potentially embarrassing" ideas.

If I am correct you hold the view that the best way to effect positive change in society is to maximize the political capital of our leaders by selecting candidates who have never had any original ideas or held any controversial positions. (And I add original ideas, since most new ideas are controversial.) However, I don't believe this is true. I believe that candidates who are intellectually curious and have intellectual integrity are the best leaders to effect change in society, since even if the public does not initially agree with all of their ideas these leaders will be in a stronger position to convince them. While I value your opinion, you have not convinced me that it is indeed correct, and so I see no reason to concede.


Now you're just dancing around. Your comment is right there at the top of the thread. All you're convincing me of now is that you'll never concede anything in a discussion, which makes you pretty boring to talk to.

Some other time, maybe, Alex.


I think I understand what you're saying. To clarify, my point was not that Obama is a hypocrite, but rather that I disagree with his policy of having candidates out themselves for having held potentially embarrassing ideas. That's what I was trying to express when I said "So apparently the change candidate wants to start by weeding out anyone who has ever spoken up against the status quo."


You continue to imply a lot of things that aren't justified by evidence. Asking about potential embarassments isn't the same thing as rejecting candidates for them.


Fair enough.


Sorry for assuming you were unreasonable. Rough morning.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: