Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

You didn’t buy a book. You bought a license for the content that can be revoked at any time. You also licensed the ebook provider to remove or alter the content as they see fit.

Don’t want changing books? Pirate your ebook or buy a paper book.




Books have been around for centuries. You can't redefine the term because lawyers. If anything, that kind of ninja editing of intellectual history is fraud on a civilizational scale.

Doesn't mean you can sell license subscriptions or whatnot, but what you sell has to match up with what the buyer thinks they're purchasing.


> You didn’t buy a book. You bought a license for the content that can be revoked at any time.

Odd, when I look at a Kindle book on Amazon it shows a button to "Buy now".

> You also licensed the ebook provider to remove or alter the content as they see fit.

It is good that at least the EU has started to recognize the concept of informed consent. Clicking agree on a multi-page contract when that is the only way to access content that you (or someone else) have already paid for is not it.

> Don’t want changing books? Pirate your ebook or buy a paper book.

Those are the immediately available options, but that doesn't mean we have to just accept digital "purchases" being whatever the seller wants them to be while still trying to lure in people by making it seem they are buying something.


They should do it with the Holy Bible. Then it can really be the "living word" of God.


The really explosive edit would be to introduce a LGBT-friendly Quran.


My casual reading of the Quran found nothing pro- or contra-LGBT. Perhaps the Hadiths are another matter...


You have to understand, LGBT-friendly today means that there are forced diversity inclusions at every corner so noone can possibly not see the progressiveness.


Probably no chance of it being converted to comic book format, to reach different audiences either. ;)


They do. NIV 1984 is not todays NIV.

(But having once reviewed a swath of inclusiveness edits via side by side comparisons first hand out of intellectual curiosity about what is going on, it was kinda a nothingburger was my takeaway.)


NIV is a translation though. Having different translations is a normal thing. Having different originals not so much.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: