Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Does this factor in with basketball, soccer (futbol), tennis, And many other sports?

Also, just my personal opinion. I’d rather make $10M over my 20s with some head trauma than have to slave away as a random cog employee. I know people can delude themselves into believing they aren’t. Some believe their work matters a lot. I doubt many would do the same work id they had millions in savings though.

This doesn’t make streamers any smarter to me. This posits that streamers would not be streamers if streaming entailed the same risk of head trauma as the NFL and hockey. I personally believe people would want the game and money so they’d still do it.




>Does this factor in with basketball, soccer (futbol), tennis, And many other sports?

My understanding is that though most of those sports have a lower rate of head trauma than football or hockey, they still have a far higher rate of head trauma than the general public. To the point where I doubt many professional soccer or basketball players haven't had at least one concussion like event from the sport.

If I were guaranteed $10m for a concussion I'd take that deal in a second. Having a high chance of a concussion for a very low chance of $10m is a different matter.

I only see streamers as smarter as their low chance of millions doesn't have the associated risk of head trauma, though I agree that it's unlikely anybody is picking their long shot based on the potential injury.

edit read your other reply and can sum up or difference in opinions easily.

>I don’t think either selects for higher intelligence

Neither do I, but I think the process for athletes has more of a negative effect on intelligence than streaming does. Purely due to injuries.


Yeah agreed. So agreeing all around hah.

What do you think about the possibility of athletes are not sitting at a desk in front of their computer screen 10 hours a day like streamers? I’m generalizing with the numbers :). Instead they are exercising? That has to count for something, no? Maybe a few streamers are doing treadmill desks but I’d think that will always remain incredibly rare. Standing desks may be used a little more but I don’t know.

I understand streamers can exercise in their own time. It is debatable if exercising for an isolated one hour a day is any where close to the same as regular fitness.


General unhealthiness is probably common with streamers but though it may decrease their expected life span, but it's nowhere near as permanently hazardous as what head injuries can do to a person. Additionally, they just aren't dedicating enough free time to taking care of themselves while athletes need to put themselves in danger for part of their sport.

And as a related aside, I think many of the actual esports teams have realized the importance of health for competitions and devote a fair amount of time to it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: