Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How is Currency Manipulator different than quantitative easing which everyone does?


China sets the price of its currency directly.

QE indirectly affects the price of your currency by manipulating the price of your bonds.


That doesn't answer the question. No reasonably advanced manipulator of any system is content to operate only on the most visible level of influence.

So the question really is, how different is a direct manipulation from an ongoing secondary manipulation?


It's extremely different!

In a free market, no one truly knows how the market will respond to some signal (like the purchase of bonds). Although an unrestrained manipulator (The Fed) can get pretty close to setting the price of all bonds by buying huge quantities of certain bonds -- The Fed doesn't know with certainty how that will affect the price of the currency (USD). And they don't really care that much, to be honest. They don't measure inflation with respect to a basket of currencies. They measure inflation with respect only to the USD.

When China literally sets the price of the RMB, there's no question what will happen to the price of the RMB. It is whatever China says it is.

There's a huge difference between manipulating the price of your currency and your bonds. And it's because there's a huge difference between what bonds and currenies are, and how they're used.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: