Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Anybody that posits an idea as 'brilliant' should go and implement it themselves.


What about people that are already in the middle of building other things (like a comics empire)? If I have (what I consider to be) ten brilliant ideas, the best thing for me, personally, to do, is to execute full-steam on one, instead of dividing my attention. Should I then let the rest rot, and perhaps be rendered moot by the passage of time and technology—or should I give them away now while they're still fresh?


You can't really say that they're brilliant yourself, that's for others to decide.

Here's an idea for you: A service that you have to check in to periodically, you set up a number of actions that need to be done after you haven't checked in for 24 hours, 48 hours, 1 week, 1 month, 1 year and 5 years.

We'll call the thing 'deadmansknob', after the button in the locomotives that a train driver has to keep pressed to activate the system (if they have a heart attack they presumably let go).

Payment is on the signing up end (since obviously you won't be paying on the other end), $1 per action on file per year.


(Double-edited: really, HN?)

Your invention sounds like the perfect kind of thing to submit to the Halfbakery: http://www.halfbakery.com/

The difference between "this should be a blog post" and "this seems like something for people to use to amuse themselves with over lunch," I think, is that the blog-post kind of idea requires very little investment in time and labor to determine profitability. The kinds of things you see on the Halfbakery (and your idea) usually require large HR-investments, with employees either manufacturing the product, or directly serving the customer (or making sure that all the stuff you want to happen after your "death" actually happens.) You can't just sit down at your terminal and see if it's a great idea by morning, so it just becomes "something nice to think about" rather than "something nice to try out."


"I would really hope that a group of people as rational as HN would see through the need for that kind of thing—the sentence decodes to an opinion either way."

Interesting writing should contain both statements of fact and opinions. Having the writer provide cues to indicate which is which makes reading easier.

Otherwise, how does one quickly distinguish between an unsupported statement of fact vs. an opinion?


This is what I originally wrote:

> If I have ten brilliant ideas, the best thing to do is to execute full-steam on one, instead of dividing my attention.

And this is the altered version:

> If I have (what I consider to be) ten brilliant ideas, the best thing for me, personally, to do, is to execute full-steam on one, instead of dividing my attention.

Now, there are things—aesthetic descriptors, like "brilliant" and "best"—that are completely subjective (except in certain jargon contexts, like "best-case efficiency.") Using an aesthetic descriptor is inherently implying that whatever you are saying is an opinion, because aesthetic descriptors have no other use—there is no way to "support" the "fact" that something is best, or most moral, or is the most dance-able, or tastes most nostalgic. These evaluations come from your utility function, not your model of the world.

All I did, here, was to add qualifiers to my aesthetic descriptors marking them as such. Frequently, I do the same to, say, a summary of a post by Zed Shaw, as a comment to that post, and people reply with "well why didn't he just say that?" It's bizarre to me, because these things are completely clear and never the subject of argument in spoken conversation—yet they seem to be points of ire almost always when online. I wonder if there's some sort of body-language cue that people normally rely on so subconsciously that they never realize they've avoided actually parsing any aesthetic qualifiers they've encountered, instead just inferring their meanings from analysis of tone and intent.


Furthermore, you already had the qualifier "if" in there.

Now that I see what you were referring to, I fully agree with you.


Not everybody's born to be an entrepreneur; not everyone likes the challenge to build things from scratch. Everyone has a comfort zone.


And that's the point. Nobody wants to put in effort to find out that their genius idea is not.


Well put. That being said, I'm happy to have put in the effort to find out that my genius idea was not. It caused me to have the right amount of humility.


Also, maybe someone does like the challenge to build things from scratch, just not companies.


Scott Adams seems to enjoy submitting ideas for discussion moreso than actually developing them. I'm guessing he's already rather financially stable, so it may not be worth the hassle to him to actually do it.


He couldn't possibly be financially stable. We know Dilbert cartoons cannot attract much audience because they lack attractive faces. Didn't you read the article? ;-)


I wish I could link directly, but there's a section in Scott McCloud's Understanding Comics that talks about attractiveness as a function of visual abstraction. The fewer details a face has, the more people will like it, because more will identify with it. Dilbert's characters, "attractive" or not, are very heavily abstracted.


He said once that he's not "private jet" rich, but he never has to think about what things cost.


It's easy to label your own ideas as brilliant if you are not going to live of them.


Between the lines, I've also read "manipulative and creepy and potentially evil". You wouldn't implement that, now would you?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: