Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Ask HN: How do you keep your ideas?
16 points by cucho on June 13, 2017 | hide | past | favorite | 20 comments
I'm thinking of tackling these two problems: (1) Ideas happen anywhere, anytime (running, in the shower, driving, etc). How to capture these ideas before they vanish?

(2) I use notebooks, but once I write down an idea chances are that I will never see it again. I have a box full of notebooks collecting dust.

I want to know how do you capture/keep your ideas (notebook, an app, eidetic memory, napkins, mails to yourself), what do you like/dislike about your current way, and what have you tried and didn't work/stick.




To solve (1), just any old scrap of paper, which is then (2) transferred to a personal wiki that lives in dropbox. I use this one (tiddlywiki.com), but anything with tagging and search would work. I appreciate the organization by time, tag, or list, and also the latex and markup support, but these are not essential. Semantic search would be even better. Ive used this to capture ideas, notes, code, writings and lists. It has been essential for my work/dissertation.

I see the personal wiki as an evolution of the commonplace book, that was kept in the past by the likes of Darwin (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonplace_book). Here are some of my notes from the book Where Good Ideas Come From

"We know much of Darwin's thinking on the development of his ideas from his extensive notebooks, which he read, and re-read and recombined. This era was the time of the 'commonplace' notebook, in which long passages of quotes from other sources and thoughts were recorded. Reading and writing were apparently quite related. These books may have struck a balance between silo'd organization, and utter chaos, allowing the development of theories beginning with hunches which could then be further developed. The key to developing a hunch into a theory appears to be writing it down "


Use the same size notebook.

Set aside front-matter pages for indexes and update them whenever you review the contents.

Write the subject, date and page number on every page.

Throw the notebooks away when they're more than ten years old. You're a different person today and if you didn't use the idea then, that idea probably isn't going to be relevant today.

Bad ideas will decay. Good ideas will echo. The hard part of the experience is knowing that 99% of your ideas will never be done.


I designed a program to do it for me.

I wrote https://mypost.io

This allows me to create single web pages in seconds complete with the ability to use HTML and CSS. Since you choose your own URL and its unique to you.. no one else can use it, so I tend not to lose those URLs. They aren't just a random jumbled bunch of letters and numbers, rather, you can either make your own, or it will grab the headline that you set.

I also implemented a feature that allows you to save all of your URLs so you can easily find them again. I've shared it with the world and many people use it. So I pretty much designed it for myself... and figured others might find a use for it too. Feel free... it's free!


A plain text file and a notebook.

Every day I transcribe the notebook into the text file.

Every time I start a terminal window it gives me the top line, and rotates it to the bottom. I then review that idea and either do something about it, or just delete it from the file.


I carry a notebook with me most places, and usually have one close enough that if an idea comes to mind, I can get to a notebook and write it down before the idea vanishes. I also run a self-hosted Mediawiki instance for Fogbeam Labs and for any ideas that are Fogbeam related (and most of mine are) I will sometimes roll it up to a page there, add related links, flesh it out further, etc.

The main problem I have is the same was what the OP alludes to: I write things down, but I don't have a good system for periodically revisiting old notebooks and reviewing previously-written-down ideas.


I just tell them to myself and think about them. Then as soon as I can I explain them to someone else and see if I can get them exited about it (and me too). That's it. IMHO if an idea is good enough that you and others would be passionate to build it and the world needs it, then it will stick with you, all the other stuff is garbage anyway, you can just let it go. This is the method I use for writing and storytelling as well as for my software projects and it is by far the best way I've found of keeping a currated high quality list of my ideas.


That's interesting.

When I'm working on a side project I tried to keep quiet about it until I get some progress going, in case the idea "exits", but maybe it's good idea to tell about it as soon as possible instead. Then if it stays it would surely be worthy.


Dropbox/ideas/ideas.txt

From any app on my Mac, I can type command-space to open a spotlight search dialog, type ideas.txt and it will open the file above.

On my phone I use http://captio.co/ to send myself a quick note to my gmail account, then I copy it to ideas.txt when I'm on my laptop.

That's it.


Thanks! How many ideas do you have in ideas.txt. How often do you read them?


I have a Trello board titled simply "Ideas", and a Card for each idea. Sometimes a description, sometimes not.


OneNote. I used to use Evernote, but one too many glitches pushed me over the edge one day. OneNote has been wonderful.


I put them in a google keep list, and whenever I feel bored or lazy I open that and pick something to work on.


I use evernote mobile app and it certainly helps me note down and organize my ideas bad or good.


I keep them in a program like google keep, but I also transcribe them into a Idea notebook.


OneNote - the Windows Key + N will pop open a new quick-note - all synced by OneNote


A "Quo Vadis" brand notebook with unruled pages and a fountain pen.


Org-mode ~/ideas.org.


+1 org-mode.

When it is something right on the spot then I will either do a voice recording on the phone, or a quick note on scrap paper. I will get it into org-mode later.

I also have all phone recordings synced to laptop via syncthing, so even if I don't transcribe, at least it is kept somewhere safe for later.


I find One Note really handy.


Google Keep




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: