Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

No, he answered that in 2011 :-). And he and many other famous (and not so famous) mathematicians contribute to MathOverflow



Math Overflow is probably one of the most hardcore SX sites there are. Even most of the easiest topics discussed are MS or PhD level math, and many (most?) of the regulars are career mathematicians. Then there's math.stackexchange.com for us mere mortals. But I believe that division did not yet exist in 2011, though.


What is generally the difference between X Overflow and x.stackexchange.com? Both are from Stack Exchange, AFAICT.


I believe the X Overflow are the old format, and are now just grandfathered in. All new ones are in the latter style.


Thanks. What I meant to ask was, given X is the same topic, what is the difference between X overflow and x.stackexchange.com? That is, if there is a general rule.

Perhaps the answer is the same: It's just age. But then if X Overflow already existed, why create a redundant x.stackexchange.com?



That is interesting. I can see the logic there, mostly I'm just impressed that both sites maintain a critical mass of activity, since (at least in recent years) SX seems to require a pretty high level of engagement to get out of perpetual beta.

Does anyone know of any other cases with two similar but distinct SX communities?


Taking a look through https://stackexchange.com/sites, I see several fairly specific programming communities:

askubuntu.com and unix.stackexchange.com

vi.stackexchange.com and emacs.stackexchange.com

stackoverflow.com and codereview.stackexchange.com


Math Overflow was created as a Stack Exchange 1.0 site, which means essentially that SE hosted the software, but everything else was done by the users that initiated the site.

A few years ago, SE stopped supporting the 1.0 sites, and Math Overflow decided to join the Stack Exchange network. They're still somewhat special, e.g. they have the right to leave the SE network again, if they would want to.


At least on the math side, MathOverflow is generally for research level questions, and math.stackexchange is for any level math, often easier, questions.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: