Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I tend to wonder about entities like Steam (well, Valve) and Spotify - and their customer base.

I wonder "What will happen when one of these companies goes away?" (ie, go out of business or such)

You may think "well, that could never happen" - and you'd be right there next door to the pioneer on the prairie, standing at the railway station waiting for his shipment of a plow direct from Sears.

...been paying attention to what is happening with Sears lately?

Or what about Radio Shack?

Companies come and go - and usually when they go, if they are a company publishing or selling IP in some manner, that IP goes away with them, or it becomes "locked away" (technically) because the owners of the IP (that is, those who may have bought it in the fire-sale when the company tanked, or afterward) don't know what to do with it (or even that it may be worth something) - and so it sits (and maybe, just maybe, one day we'll see it again - but in most cases, its gone forever).

I can point to any number of distributors of music, magazines, and books where it is impossible to get a copy of what they distributed; if you're lucky, archive.org may have a copy - but in many cases, those copies are long lost (ever seen the magazine called "Horseless Carriage"? It was one of the early precursors to magazines like "Car and Driver" today, covering a new-fangled invention. Good luck finding all of the issues which were published. Good luck finding the proofs or whatever was used back then, either. All of that IP, which many would love a copy of - myself included - gone, with the exception a what you can still find that has been scanned in).

One of these days, Valve or Spotify will go under. Will you still be able to play your music catalog? Will you be able to pass it down to your heirs when you pass away? What about your games that you "bought"? Will you still be able to play them (what happens when the servers go away?) or pass them or...

No - it hasn't happened yet, and probably won't happen tomorrow. But I expect to see it happen, sometime. The results probably will get ugly.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: