Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

So exercise is good, fasting is good, heat is good, cold is good. It seems all short term stress is good.

I'm waiting for the study that shows binge drinking is good :)




"hormesis" is the idea that a stressful thing in small amounts can often have a positive effect. http://gettingstronger.org/ is an excellent website on hormesis applied to a bunch of common problems (eg. improving eyesight, eliminating back pain, eliminating allergies, curing insomnia, eliminating obesity, stopping procrastination, overcoming addictions, etc.)


Have there been clinical studies of doing this to correct eyesight? A few years ago I would hear radio ads, which struck several of my snake-oil buttons, and they've totally disappeared from the radio, which presses a few more.

(Because I'm feeling kind I won't even make you groan by asking if the studies were double-blind.)


And it appears to even apply to radiation:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hormesis


You know it's a bullshit site when they claim myopia can be reversed.

That's some cult-level wishful thinking.


When I discover I've been served undercooked meat, I immediately graduate to tequila shots: http://www.nytimes.com/2005/02/15/health/the-claim-drinking-...


>binge drinking is good

We all wish. Binge drinking is great if you want to put on some fat :) Sorry, I have some bad news for you.

The evidence here is unfortunately pretty strong - binge drinking causes all sorts of negative effects, upsetting your metabolism and muscle synthesis.

Population studies of alcohol consumption overall show that even minimal drinking habits (1/day) increase your risk of death from various cancers and issues. It's offset by reduction in cardiovascular deaths until a break-even of about 3/day for men.

Most of these studies are self-reported, based off correlation not causation. Health problems lead some to a reduction in drinking. I'm unconvinced the benefits are real. We just enjoy drinking too damn much.

A standard drink is often much less than what we'll consider a drink. A 20oz pint of some strong craft beer can hit 3 standard drinks. Optimal dosages based on a health Canada study were 0.25 drinks for women and 0.5 for men. Enjoy your half-can of beer!

Don't drink for the health benefits. They're at best overstated and, if they do exist, are likely better obtained by doing something we've actually tested for causality.


>Binge drinking is great if you want to put on some fat

I know you're joking, but even if you were looking to get fat, there're still better ways to do it.

If your aim was to get hungover, then maybe drinking is the best way, haha.


> I'm waiting for the study that shows binge drinking is good :)

I'm convinced a decent session has seen off an impending cold on occasions. Presumably by giving my antibodies a home advantage.


Fasting seems like the opposite of stress- your digestive tract isn't actually doing anything


Actually, you're well off, but not for the reason you think. Let me explain.

Fasting invokes all your counter-regulatory hormones: cortisol, adrenaline, others but they are the big players - because not having easy access to sugar leads to a stress response.

So it isn't gut rest, it's physiological phase change that is causing the stress response


How long is the stress response ? is it only transient before switching to a "fasting" regime or is it long lasting ?


I guess depends on your definition of a stress response; most people would consider it to be a 'stress response' whilst you have high adrenergic/sympathetic activity. Upon activation of the parasympathetic nervous system there will be a gradual decrease in cortisol and a rapid decrease in adrenaline.

Thyroid hormone is also going to be implicated somewhere along with a host of other hormones so I have simplified but suffice to say it's shades of grey on the way in and out


Two days of fasting apparently causes metabolically expensive parts of the immune system to go into low-power mode w/ white blood cell apoptosis. Resuming eating on day three reboots everything and you end up a fresh young army of white blood cells.


Anywhere i can read more about this? low-power mode and reboots are two terms that are used a lot by mommy bloggers selling ebooks promoting fad diets. Is there any published researchers that talks about this?


Not using those specific terms, unsurprisingly, but this may be of interest: https://news.usc.edu/63669/fasting-triggers-stem-cell-regene...


Stress is not about doing a lot, it's about being anxious.

The digestive tract may not do anything, but the body gets into "we're fighting possible starvation" mode.


The word stress has a broader meaning than the mental/anxiety aspect though.


digestive tract maybe not, but metabolism/endocrine system does actually respond.


I think the stress in that case comes from your body reacting to not having food.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: