Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

"People like me"... always a non-starter; it tells me that you're arguing with a model of who I am in your head, that probably has more to do with the people you argued with in the past than anything to do with me.

I don't think nukes end conventional militaries, but I think they end conventional conflicts between nuclear armed nations. That's why we're fighting Russia in a proxy war in Syria, and not with tanks in the Ukraine. As for China, how many times could our navy and air force obliterate them as it stands? Besides, they're just taking a page from our book, letting us front the R&D, then... stealing the designs.

Much cheaper, much smarter.




"People like you" isn't a non-starter if they just mean "people who think nukes end the need for competitive conventional capabilities", and the justification for such a model can be gathered entirely in this thread.


The "like you" part may be completely unjustified - especially when M_Grey said "I don't think nukes end conventional militaries".


He has however made it clear he thinks we don't need them to be competitive, which is why I used that word.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: