Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/07/16/business/dealbook/the-c... is a reasonable explanation of why this isn't really a loophole.


The Klinsky explanation you linked to is borderline disingenuous. Nah, it's just disingenuous.

It's exhausting and daunting to list all the ways that Klinsky's ELI5 example is meaningfully different from what really happens in PE-land.

What it comes down to is this: PE managers get a success fee for managing other people's money without putting up their own, which is very very normal, and usually counts as earned income (normal tax rate).

However, when certain very specific circumstances apply, a bit of the tax code lets you legally pretend that instead of a success fee, the amount you get paid is a return on invested capital.

Very plainly, the pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, HNWIs, etc. who put up the actual risk capital into the PE funds are putting dollars at risk and earning a return on invested capital.

If one simply does the exercise of asking, "where are the dollars that the PE manager put at risk?" the lie is exposed.

My personal pet peeve on this is that, back in the 1970s, it was actually the case that the general partners would have had unlimited liability and therefore really were, after a fashion, putting the entirety of their capital at risk to earn the carry. But since the 1990s at least and probably earlier, everyone in this game has used a pass-through LLC blocker entity to limit the personal liability of the managers. So they keep all the tax benefit but give up that pesky "risk" part.

(Partnership structures and carried interest actually do have other things to recommend them as ways of aligning interests and making deals work. But pretending that the contingent, earned, success-based portion of income accruing to the manager is a return on risk capital invested for tax purposes is just a total fiction.)


> However, when certain very specific circumstances apply, a bit of the tax code lets you legally pretend that instead of a success fee, the amount you get paid is a return on invested capital.

I'd love to see an explanation of why it makes any sense to continue treating capital gains income (i.e. "return on invested capital") any differently than ordinary income. If we fixed that, then the carried interest "loophole" would cease to be relevant because it wouldn't change the tax rates paid.

I don't see why the tax code should incentivize passive investment over actual work.


> I don't see why the tax code should incentivize passive investment over actual work.

Well it doesn't.

It incentivises savings over spending, and working over not-working.

For example of the latter, I receive an income: What should I do with the money I do not spend on rent, food, transport, and education? Should I just work less because I don't need that money?

Why don't I just invest it? If I work more, then I will have more money to invest!

However because of inflation, any money I put into savings evaporates if I have to pay both income tax on the new earnings and have to suffer the loss in buying power due to inflation. The difference must be at least what the actual inflation turns out to be over however many years we want people saving. Darn.

If we work backwards, we can see the reasons: If we give up gold, we can control inflation with maths instead drilling, and with a lower capital gains tax then people can spend and work more.

See, this isn't as simple as you want it to be, but it makes more sense than you might think. Our tax code is based around thousands of little tests and questions like this that, and a big part of why it is so complicated has to do with the sheer amount of time we have spent arguing about how much tax is fair.

> I'd love to see an explanation of why it makes any sense to continue treating capital gains income (i.e. "return on invested capital") any differently than ordinary income

You can use Google to search for exactly that. You will get a lot of results because there are a lot of different reasons.


> Why don't I just invest it?

You're assuming that investment actually happens. The widening wealth gap refutes that assumption; wealth is accumulating at the high end and not being re-invested back in the rest of the economy. The poor recovery from the last few financial crisis is more evidence, "You can lead a bank to liquidity, but you can't make it lend."

> If we give up gold, we can control inflation with maths

Giving up the gold standard is orthogonal to the tax rate for capital gains. This is completely off topic.

> See, this isn't as simple as you want it to be

The economy is fantastically complex. It's also very unpredictable due to the inter-dependencies, even if some people like to pretend otherwise. Hubris doesn't make inherently unstable models[1] into a useful result.

[1] "Understanding economics well impedes an understanding the economy." -- Yanis Varoufakis[2]

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L5AUAIzciLE#t=1355


The widening wealth gap refutes that assumption; wealth is accumulating at the high end and not being re-invested back in the rest of the economy.

A widening wealth gap can only occur if the wealthy are investing their money and getting good returns on it.

If the wealthy were hoarding their money, then it would not be growing and the wealth gap would shrink (since worker's wealth would increase, and the wealthy would consume some of their wealth).


> A widening wealth gap can only occur if the wealthy are investing their money

That's simply not true. If the rich are reinvesting all of their wealth... we wouldn't have a wealth gap. This is almost a tautology.

Why do you think interest rates have been kept so low? Regulators (e.g. the Fed, ECB) have been doing everything they can over the last few years to add liquidity into the market in the hope that it get banks to lend again.

> If the wealthy were hoarding their money, then it would not be growing

Life is rarely black and white. We're talking about people that have more than enough money to both invest as they desire and hoard a lot of money. The ability to do both increases as the wealth gap widens.

> since worker's wealth would increase

This is pure fantasy. How would worker wealth increase? They don't have enough money to invest, and they don't have the political power they once had. Worker wealth is going down as money accumulates in the hands of the few.

> and the wealthy would consume some of their wealth

Consumption (even large amounts) costs are insignificant when your wealth is sufficiently large.


That's simply not true. If the rich are reinvesting all of their wealth... we wouldn't have a wealth gap. This is almost a tautology.

Rich guy has wealth X. He invests it all and 1 time period later he has X(1+R).

If the poor guy has worse investment opportunities (as Piketty claims), then the poor guy will have wealth only x(1+r). Here x < X is the poor guy's wealth, and r < R is the poor guy's investment growth rate.

The gap grows by (1+R)/(1+r).

In contrast, if the rich guy hoarded he would only have wealth X, while the poor guy would have x(1+r). The gap would shrink by 1/(1+r).

If, as you postulate, the rich guy invests k of his wealth and hoards (1-k) then the gap would change at the rate (1+kR)/(1+r). More hoarding = smaller k = slower growth (or shrinkage) of wealth gap.

Life is rarely black and white.

Try doing the math and you'll see it sometimes is.


What you don't seem to understand is that "r" is 0 for a very large portion of the country, and in many cases is even negative.

> the poor guy's investment

Except in rare cases, this doesn't exist.

> Try doing the math

The math is simple. The problem is your data seems to be based more on wishful thinking than actual experience and research.


My arithmetic is based only on the definition of hoarding (holding wealth without investing it) and Thomas Picketty's claim - which you just agreed with - that R > r.

Why don't you do your own arithmetic to demonstrate my error?


While I am skeptical that it's the case, you seem to have missed the assertion that r < 0. In that case, the "shrinking" of the wealth gap by 1/(1+r) would be more accurately termed a growing by 1/(1-r).


> You're assuming that investment actually happens.

Of course! I am assuming that investment actually happens because I put money in my savings account and I receive interest.


> I put money in my savings account and I receive interest.

You do? I think you're an outlier there. Is that rate beating inflation?

I count the .15% rate on my savings account as a joke, rather than any sort of meaningful interest.


You should talk to your bank: Mine offers a savings account that just beats inflation if I don't take a withdrawal that I can use for an emergency fund, and once you have an emergency fund set up you can put further savings into fixed-term accounts which actually generate "meaningful interest".


As a HN member, there is a high probability that you receive a comfortable salary. Please realize that this probably puts you in a position of (some) privilege when you interact with banks. For much of the country that lives paycheck-to-paycheck, paying rent and buying food/gas take priority over maintaining the minimum balance that is usually required in accounts that pay interest.


The economics of taxation are fairly well understood, and they make it clear that not all taxes are equal. In particular, some taxes have higher "deadweight losses" than others, which mean it is much less efficient and more damaging to the economy and to society to rely on them for revenue generation.

And listing commonly discusses taxes from lowest to highest deadweight losses, it goes: Land value tax, property taxes, consumption taxes, income taxes, capital taxes.

> I don't see why the tax code should incentivize passive investment over actual work.

Because to do otherwise causes real harm to all of us, because while even a large tax on, eg, land doesn't notably change the supply of land, a small tax on investment income does reduce the supply of investment. And reduced investment lowers productivity across the industry, reducing worker compensation and making us all as a society poorer.

In short: You get less of what you tax. That makes taxing eg, CO2 production a great idea (we want less of that!), and taxing investment a pretty bad one.

(More generally: The tax code is the worst possible way to do income redistribution, and the American obsession with trying leads to really poor outcomes. If you want to help the poor, try giving them actual money. Regressive taxes funding a progressive welfare state works; the reverse does not.)


We have an oversupply of capital which is causing a wide range of problems. Taxing capital gains at a higher rate than income is likely a good idea. Remember companies don't become more profitable if there stock price increases.

PS: ROI directly relates to the supply of capital.


> We have an oversupply of capital which is causing a wide range of problems.

Citation very, very much needed.


Mortgage backed securities. I could go on, but as ever lower ROI becomes competitive money gets sloshed around the financial system, creating economic distortions such as housing booms backed by investors. Most clearly building a house that's sitting vacant is a waste of resources and caused by similar forces as the infamous Pets.com etc etc.


> The tax code is the worst possible way to do income redistribution, and the American obsession with trying leads to really poor outcomes.

Northern Europe would like to disagree, and to point out that Americans are far from obsessed with this. Take Mitt Romney: in 2012 he disclosed paying 15% taxes on his around $15 mill./year income. In a reasonable country he'd be paying at least 35%!

Actual progressive taxation without loopholes, together with a properly implemented public health service, ending the health insurance industry, government-funded parental leave for the first year of a child's life, and otherwise socially responsible policies (ending the prison industry that disproportionally targets the poor and non-whites, ending the war on drugs etc) is a great way of doing income redistribution and society improvements.


> Northern Europe would like to disagree, and to point out that Americans are far from obsessed with this. Take Mitt Romney: in 2012 he disclosed paying 15% taxes on his around $15 mill./year income. In a reasonable country he'd be paying at least 35%!

The overwhelming majority of Northern European countries have a lower top marginal tax rate than that that on dividends and capital gains. So apparently Sweden, France, Germany, Finland, Norway, etc. aren't "reasonable countries"?


There are exceptions like Romney, but they don't really add up to much. The US has a more progressive tax system than Western Europe: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/04/05/ameri...

The top 10% in the US pay a substantially larger share of taxes than their share of income. In Sweden they pay the same share of taxes as their share of income.


Inflation is one reason, as the capital "gains" resulting from inflation are taxed.

Another reason is businesses need investment capital. Do you want to incentivize people providing that, or discourage it?


Carried interest, in my opinion isn't a capital gain unless the investor's own capital is at risk. However, let's talk about 'normal' capital gains. When you risk your own capital, you are obviously going after a reward, however the downside is that you can lose your capital. So a lower tax rate makes sense in order to incentivize the risk. Look at the property market in France for instance: the housing market is far less liquid than the US and that results in much higher housing prices because fewer people are going to sell their property if they lose 50% of the gain to taxes. That constricts supply and increases prices. There is definitely more to French housing than that, but the point is that high taxation reduces the benefit of selling something which disincentivizes selling, resulting in higher prices which doesn't harm the property owner as much as people trying to buy houses. In other words, high capital gains taxes reduces market liquidity. That means that capital that could be invested in something else is 'locked up' in an asset that isn't profitable to sell. That means some startup or some small business can't get access to capital they need to grow and expand -- or even get started in the first place. Look at VC activity in France vs. San Francisco. The difference isn't entirely cultural but a result of more expensive capital. Many European investors are far more conservative than US investors not because they want to be but because the incentives are stacked against aggressive or innovative investing, the types of which are responsible for many of the companies at which many people reading this work.

So why incentivize risking own's capital? $1 million could seed a company that grows to dozens of employees, while if that $1 million were taxed at 50% that means that the government has to use the resulting $500k to provide utility for society. $500k could mathematically provide 10 jobs at $50k per year for one year. However, that million dollar seeded startup could create dozens of jobs as well as tax revenue from the resulting profit as well as tax income from all of the employees. A highly highly simplified example but the point is that a million in the marketplace has the potential to become multi-millions in future tax revenue. While that money in government doesn't have the same force multiplier potential unless you profess that we are on the far left of the Rahn Curve and government isn't yet big enough to support maximal economic output.

My long drawn out point: incentivizing capital gains incebtivizes economic growth. Carried interest (on other people's capital) however is another issue altogether: essentially that's a commission when it's being treated like a capital gain.


I don't but this argument about risk. If you risk your capital and lose it (long-term), you get a deductible loss, which, due to the oddities of the US tax code, is mostly only deductible against long-term gains. If capital gains were just ordinary income, then you'd get an ordinary loss if you lost money and could use it as a deduction against any income whatsoever.

In any event, from memory, the idea of long-term capital gains was to incentivize the long-term holding of stocks, and it sounded like a good idea, but as I seem to recall no one ever found any real evidence that it provided a benefit.

So I'll re-ask my question: why does the government need to give a specific incentive for long-term holding of equities and similar instruments?

I can give reasons that it's a bad idea:

1. It's very hard to define "long-term capital gains" in a coherent manner. Witness, for example, carried interest. Look at section 1256 for another strange example.

2. The combination of low long-term capital gains rate and the general inability of the IRS to collect corporate taxes from large companies means that US persons who own a stake in a large company can have turn their company's pre-tax profits into post-tax cash in the back at a very low effective rate.

3. It gives people a perverse incentive to hold on to stocks they don't like until they've had them for a year. Similarly, it gives a perverse incentive to do things that aren't quite a wash sale to hedge risks. I'm glad that there's a demand for creative financial engineering that exists solely because of an overcomplicated tax code.

I would much rather see a system in which the US didn't try to heavily tax corporate profits and instead taxed the money when it was recieved by people, which could be achieved by taxing the gains as ordinary income.


> If you risk your capital and lose it (long-term), you get a deductible loss, which, due to the oddities of the US tax code, is mostly only deductible against long-term gains.

Long term capital losses first offset long term capital gains. Short term capital losses first offset short term capital gains. After that, capital losses of either type offset capital gains of the other type. It's quite common (and beneficial if the timing works out) to use long-term capital loss carryover to offset short-term capital gains.


I would assume the obvious solution in France would be to take out a loan of 50-80% of the property price, instead of selling it + paying the taxes. Mortgage interest rates are relatively low, and you can use that money to reinvest. Every country has its tax quirks but also usually has a solution for it. Deferring taxes is generally a lot easier than avoiding them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: