I don't but this argument about risk. If you risk your capital and lose it (long-term), you get a deductible loss, which, due to the oddities of the US tax code, is mostly only deductible against long-term gains. If capital gains were just ordinary income, then you'd get an ordinary loss if you lost money and could use it as a deduction against any income whatsoever.
In any event, from memory, the idea of long-term capital gains was to incentivize the long-term holding of stocks, and it sounded like a good idea, but as I seem to recall no one ever found any real evidence that it provided a benefit.
So I'll re-ask my question: why does the government need to give a specific incentive for long-term holding of equities and similar instruments?
I can give reasons that it's a bad idea:
1. It's very hard to define "long-term capital gains" in a coherent manner. Witness, for example, carried interest. Look at section 1256 for another strange example.
2. The combination of low long-term capital gains rate and the general inability of the IRS to collect corporate taxes from large companies means that US persons who own a stake in a large company can have turn their company's pre-tax profits into post-tax cash in the back at a very low effective rate.
3. It gives people a perverse incentive to hold on to stocks they don't like until they've had them for a year. Similarly, it gives a perverse incentive to do things that aren't quite a wash sale to hedge risks. I'm glad that there's a demand for creative financial engineering that exists solely because of an overcomplicated tax code.
I would much rather see a system in which the US didn't try to heavily tax corporate profits and instead taxed the money when it was recieved by people, which could be achieved by taxing the gains as ordinary income.
> If you risk your capital and lose it (long-term), you get a deductible loss, which, due to the oddities of the US tax code, is mostly only deductible against long-term gains.
Long term capital losses first offset long term capital gains. Short term capital losses first offset short term capital gains. After that, capital losses of either type offset capital gains of the other type. It's quite common (and beneficial if the timing works out) to use long-term capital loss carryover to offset short-term capital gains.
In any event, from memory, the idea of long-term capital gains was to incentivize the long-term holding of stocks, and it sounded like a good idea, but as I seem to recall no one ever found any real evidence that it provided a benefit.
So I'll re-ask my question: why does the government need to give a specific incentive for long-term holding of equities and similar instruments?
I can give reasons that it's a bad idea:
1. It's very hard to define "long-term capital gains" in a coherent manner. Witness, for example, carried interest. Look at section 1256 for another strange example.
2. The combination of low long-term capital gains rate and the general inability of the IRS to collect corporate taxes from large companies means that US persons who own a stake in a large company can have turn their company's pre-tax profits into post-tax cash in the back at a very low effective rate.
3. It gives people a perverse incentive to hold on to stocks they don't like until they've had them for a year. Similarly, it gives a perverse incentive to do things that aren't quite a wash sale to hedge risks. I'm glad that there's a demand for creative financial engineering that exists solely because of an overcomplicated tax code.
I would much rather see a system in which the US didn't try to heavily tax corporate profits and instead taxed the money when it was recieved by people, which could be achieved by taxing the gains as ordinary income.