Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't understand this recurrent point: computer power is "wasted" almost everywhere. At least Bitcoin use this power to build a decentralized currency.


> computer power is "wasted" almost everywhere. At least Bitcoin use this power to build a decentralized currency.

Pinning a GPU or ASIC at 100% undeniably draws more power than an everyday user idling around Facebook on their Macbook Air (~21W MAXED, so likely 7W)

Whether it's worth it is the question.

A back-of-the-envelope calculation gives me $12Mn USD per day as the approximate global cost of electricity given the current global hashrate of 375Mn GH/s, for 0.05¢/kWh, assuming everyone is using reasonably modern, efficient (?) ASICs like a Spondoolies SP35 Yukon at 5.5TH/s for 3850W.

If that's for a $300Mn USD daily market, that's not particularly efficient. Nor particularly inefficient either, admittedly. Democratic, for sure ;)

EDIT: initially forgot to include some time units, thanks jsprogrammer!


> A back-of-the-envelope calculation gives me $12Mn USD per day

3600.00 BTC or $1m is paid as subsidy per day.

Are you saying that people are spending 12x that on power?

I dont think so.


Do your own calculation and see what you find, instead of think. This is HN after all. :)

You have all the relevant numbers in my post after all: maybe I made a mistake? That certainly possible :P, since you seem to be right about the rewards paid per day.

Or maybe people willingly factor in power costs as a price of speculating on a volatile, trending currency? Or maybe most power costs are actually carried in low-cost areas rather than North America and Europe, so my $0.05/kWh is an overestimate?


>$12Mn USD

per what?

This number is pretty meaningless without knowing what timeframe that amount of costs are incurred.


Oops, good save. Thanks!

It's per day. (I think. :P)

Today's average hashrate is ~397Mn GH/s, and I used 375 instead, to be conservative/fair.

https://blockchain.info/charts/hash-rate


The spot price of BTC has been steadily rising. Someone must be getting more than $12,000,000 USD / day in value out of it.


It's wasted relative to other methods (e.g. proof of stake, Stellar) that many people believe can provide close enough to the same properties.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: