Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

When an Indian leaves the country to go west, he's made to feel like a traitor for leaving his "motherland". A lot of Indians live with some form of guilt for having a happy and healthy life outside India. The guilt takes some people like the ones mentioned in this article to go back and do some good for the country.

I think Indians at home need to realise that there is a world outside India. It's exciting, it's beautiful and it's worth exploring. It's OK to not live in India. There are a billion people there already. The country can do with losing some.

The closest we can get to a world without borders is for people to take the chance to go and live in another country, when they can.



The problem is they're losing the most ambitious and the most intelligent, the ones who could help the country the most.

However, the country was wasting those resources anyway.


"Brain drain" is often cited as the problem. I doubt it has as big an impact as people claim it to have.

Even though a fraction of the top talent leaves, there are a lot of very intelligent and talented people in India who don't leave the country.

The biggest thing that's holding back development in India is the one thing which Indians are very proud of: culture. In a country where you have to respect people purely based on age and status, bad ideas will continue to win.


Exactly! Most people forgets that india has more population than USA and Europe combined!

http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=us+population+%2B+europ...

They don't lack people who can make a difference, they lack the proper environment to make a difference. You can take all the best and the brightest of the world to india and it would not make _much_ difference unless the government initiates the right environment for change.


Great use of WA. Slightly easier to parse: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=indian+population+/+(us...

The graph is especially interesting.


Yours is definitely better. I was just trying to do something quickly on the run to make point. Its really amazing how much population India has and Indian politicians cry foul about getting all the successful Indian people from developed nation hoping to make a change.

The change has to come within.


"When an Indian leaves the country to go west, he's made to feel like a traitor for leaving his "motherland"."

By whom, exactly? I haven't had a single friend or relative imply that I am a traitor. Yes, many tell me I should come back because they miss me, because it would be good for me now that India is booming and it would be good for the country.

There will always be some people with extreme opinions, but I don't think your generalization is true to any substantial degree.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: