Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Ask HN: Why am I getting asked to review books?
2 points by lukevella on April 17, 2015 | hide | past | favorite | 1 comment
I've been approached to review books a number of times now. I'm curious to know if this is common or not. Has anyone here been approached to do a book review? If yes, have you ever gone through with one? How does it work? Is it worth doing?

From my experience, in return for the review you get 2 free copies of the book and a mention.




I have written several thousand review articles over the last dozen years or so. Reviews of (in descending order) comics, books, films and albums, for diverse print and digital media. It is possible that those who approached you sincerely would like your take specifically. That does happen, but more often, I have found, is the case of reviewing being a cheap effort at adcopy.

Honestly, I feel that aside from family and friends of those responsible for the source work, reviews generally go unread by the bulk of the masses. I really think most PR persons are incredibly lazy, and instead of making efforts to think outside of boxes, rely heavily on the old standbys of reviews, interviews, and press releases (ready for copy and pasting among the blogging elite). If the creator responsible is not "a name", then PR persons are compelled to get someone, anyone, to view the work. And then, more often than not, the PR persons pray that such person will do the selling for them.

I realize this sounds bitter. (I've spent far more efforts on promoting indie creators than I have on developing my own works, to very mixed results.) But ultimately, composing review articles is essentially unpaid adcopy work. I think a strong review should be handled along the lines of a high school book report. The habit can be a neat exercise unto itself, as far as writing in general. But there are many snakes in the grass.

All said, if the work/s in question truly strike you (for good or ill), then by all means have a go at formulating your opinion on the matter for others. If only for the sake of trying something new. But be weary of getting locked into it. You do one review, then the publisher or producer may well send you another soon enough. And as I am fond of saying, inundation only suits dry fields.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: