When we're this deep into a comment chain, you just need to wait for a few minutes before the "Reply" button appears. Design in HN to slow down flame wars, I suppose.
I think you make good points. People say things like "don't ever talk to a police without lawyer", because they want to make a political point.
I am not American, and not resident in the US, but I do not believe that a total "I don't talk to police without lawyer, ever" is really wise. Either in US or elsewhere - you have to understand your surroundings.
My latest interaction with an American police officer was on a business trip on September 12, 2001. Independent of the bad TV shows the previous day, I was driving to the local office where I was visiting. Boss from Europe called me on my cell phone. I didn't think it was a good idea to speak on the phone while driving, so I took the exit from highway and stopped on the curb of a smaller road. After talking for a moment, I noticed a police car stopped next to me. I rolled down the window, and the police asked me why I stopped there. I told him, to speak on the phone. He told me to move over because I would be blocking other traffic. I hadn't noticed it but he was right. I said "sorry, I didn't notice, I'll get moving", put the phone away and got moving. End of story.
Instead of telling him "Speaking on the phone", should I have responded with "No comment, I want my lawyer"? That would have been absurd, and probably a very good reason for this officer to get suspicious of me, possibly starting to check my papers - which I'm sure he's the right to do - and possibly ticket me for simply breaking the traffic law and then being a prick about it.
I think you make good points. People say things like "don't ever talk to a police without lawyer", because they want to make a political point.
I am not American, and not resident in the US, but I do not believe that a total "I don't talk to police without lawyer, ever" is really wise. Either in US or elsewhere - you have to understand your surroundings.
My latest interaction with an American police officer was on a business trip on September 12, 2001. Independent of the bad TV shows the previous day, I was driving to the local office where I was visiting. Boss from Europe called me on my cell phone. I didn't think it was a good idea to speak on the phone while driving, so I took the exit from highway and stopped on the curb of a smaller road. After talking for a moment, I noticed a police car stopped next to me. I rolled down the window, and the police asked me why I stopped there. I told him, to speak on the phone. He told me to move over because I would be blocking other traffic. I hadn't noticed it but he was right. I said "sorry, I didn't notice, I'll get moving", put the phone away and got moving. End of story.
Instead of telling him "Speaking on the phone", should I have responded with "No comment, I want my lawyer"? That would have been absurd, and probably a very good reason for this officer to get suspicious of me, possibly starting to check my papers - which I'm sure he's the right to do - and possibly ticket me for simply breaking the traffic law and then being a prick about it.