Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Dog owner and cat owner here (I love them!) but my question is, why do we needs pets at all? Is it right to put a bird in a cage or a cat in a small apt or having a dog and bring him out just 3 times a day? Why we are so selfish to prevent birds from flying or cats from hunting? Should we rethink in general about the pet in general?


Certainly, yes. Most people don't treat their pets properly.

If you have a dog you should have it with you all the time; they're pack animals and get anxious and neurotic when left alone. This means there are very few lifestyles that lend themselves to dog ownership. Farmers tend to make great dog owners, because the dog is fully integrated with the lifestyle.

The social problem is that a lot of pet owners conflate the needs of their pet with their own personal rights. "I own a dog," and "Dogs need to be with their owners," therefore "I should be able to take my dog with me everywhere." No, you should have to stay with your dog in an appropriate environment. If you don't live in such an environment, don't own a dog.


> they're pack animals and get anxious and neurotic when left alone.

Get a second dog.

> No, you should have to stay with your dog in an appropriate environment. If you don't live in such an environment, don't own a dog.

How do you know dogs prefer to be put down than occasionally left to chill home alone?


The alternative is not putting them down, but rather to stop breeding them.

Also "occasionally left home to chill" does not describe a typical domestic dog's life. More like "left at home all day, five days a week."


Dogs breed themselves just fine - ever been to a shelter?


They breed because irresponsible people (breeders and owners alike) let them breed.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: