Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm not an expert, but I nevertheless will give my opinion.

This is based on a peer review article in an indexed journal. There is a lot of crap in peer review articles in an indexed journal, but the proportion of crap is much lower than in a random internet article. This is a good signal.

> The physicists' work builds on previous research that has shown that anyons can arise due to the fractional quantum Hall effect. To realize this effect, a 2-D electron gas is sandwiched between two flat semiconductor plates. When cooled to temperatures near absolute zero and exposed to strong magnetic fields, excitations form in the 2-D electron gas and give rise to anyons. [!] So far, only Abelian anyons have been detected in fractional quantum Hall systems, but studies suggest that non-Abelian anyons might also be realized.

I went to a seminar talk in the university about the fractional quantum Hall effect and anyons about 20 years ago, so up to the [!] mark, it sound very legit (more info: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional_quantum_Hall_effect , http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anyon ). I'm not sure about the last past of the paragraph, but it sounds good.

Anyons are quasiparticles, they are not actual particles, buy some arrangement of the electrons and atoms. They only live in 2D layers. In solid state physics is usual to treat quasiparticles as actual particles. (This is strange at first, but this is a good idea.)

The rest of the article discuss about anyons tunelling between two 2D layers and forming braid patterns. I really don't have more information about this part but it sounds reasonable. I'll not be surprised if an expert says that this is true. (This is published in a peer review article in an indexed journal, so I guess they are experts :).)

As usual, there is probably a little of hype in the research article and in the press coverage, so remember to use the standard conversion table http://xkcd.com/678/

> Can anyone with more knowledge opine on whether this is genius or quackery?

I'm classifying this as "interesting".



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: