Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is why I think non-documentary movie making of the lives of historical people is a fool's errand. Of course Hollywood had to sex up Turing. He's a pretty boring guy by Hollywood hero standards. There was no big breakthrough with the Enigma. Well, there was, but it was a Polish team that figured it out. Obviously, his sexuality is a dramatic point in his life, but that's not much to build a movie on. I really wonder if a decent documentary team was granted 1/10th the budget of this movie, what would their output be? Probably a decent and educational flick.

Its also a weird production. I'm not even sure who made this movie. It seems that it was produced by a near non-entity called Black Bear Pictures out of NYC, which shows only this movie and three others on their webpage. It was directed by a nobody with 3 other mediocre films under his belt and written by a novice writer. It really has "pet indie project of a wealthy person or two" written all over it. Shame really, a more mature and historically serious team probably would have punched out a better film.

There's a great Turing/Enigma/WWII film to be made, and this just isn't it. Considering its poor box office response (only 1m so far), I imagine this will be the only one, ever for Turing. I really feel his story is Spielberg or Scorsese worthy, but now alas, Turing is established as box office poison.



It looks like the movie is playing in only 8 theaters in the United States. I saw it in NYC where it was only playing in 1 theater.

http://www.boxofficemojo.com/daily/chart/?view=1day&sortdate...

Sort by average and it wins. It was a very entertaining movie. It would do well in a wider release.


It is being released more widely. From Wikipedia: "The film will expand into additional markets in 12 December and will be released nationwide on Christmas day".




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: