Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Ok, now as being someone right in the middle of implementing yet another ide/editor, I gotta ask, how's such a feature useful to you at all? What would it provide? Except just looking cool at a glance.


I tend to rely on my spatial reasoning a lot, even when programming -- as I suspect many other programmers do.

When working on large project files, I find that I have to spend a lot of time scrolling up and down trying to find a particular function, especially if a project file contains lots of similar-looking wrapper functions. OTOH, in my brain, I know exactly where, spatially, the function resides relative to the document. I just have to find it.

So for me, the mini-map is a huge win, on the level of, "oh wow, how have I been programming all this time without it?"

And I loathe pop-up and drop-down menus with all of my function names. They only resolve one tiny aspect of my hunting; I don't have to scroll, but I still have to find the function I'm looking for.

With mini-map, I should be able to zero in on any part of the code that I'm looking for with a single click. I really want that.


Reasonable explanation, thanks.


Must be able to check my email ;) Or really provide a extension system so I could do that.


I was only referring to the mini map feature. While you, my friend, are definitely rooting for an emacs discussion :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: