It's quite likely, as others have pointed out, that you're interpreting the exchange a little too literally.
Gruber's retort is quite weak though, not so much because it's mean-spirited or logically flawed - it's just not nearly as well-written and amusing as the original. This outcome should have been obvious to Gruber - Lyons writes a popular humor blog, Gruber does not. Trying to respond in kind, however good naturedly, ends up simply restating that well-known fact.