Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I wonder about things like:

1. sudden road changes, like the appearance of potholes

2. avoiding puddles which can cause one side of your car to hydroplane

3. taking a 'rain line' when the road is wet. (Traffic tends to put slight ruts in the road. They're enough to make slight puddles. If you drive slightly off-center, your tires will be on the high spots and less likely to hydroplane, that's that 'rain line'.)

4. avoiding icy spots



One of the reasons Mountain view is a good test bed is the comparative absence of weather.

The LIDAR system the car relies on doesn't work in rain, snow, or fog. Also, it would have a lot of trouble with the massive changes to roads and driving patterns caused by seasonal snow accumulation in the mid-west and north east.


That's why the car has a ton of sensors all over it. For modeling all the dynamic behavior occurring on or around the previously-modeled road.

It's much easier for the on-board processing to start with a baseline and then figure out how the world differs than to start from scratch from the sensors.


Detecting puddles can be awfully tricky, they can be lighter than the road or darker than the road, depending on the angle of the light.

There are other issues, too, such as I've been behind gravel trucks that were constantly dropping gravel, and other vehicles with a clearly unstable load that I get away from. I also give wide berth to cars that don't appear to be driven in a stable manner.


5. Areas that are often covered in deep snow. If "curbs" are defined as the raised area next to the street that you can't drive over, then the curbs change from one day to the next, jutting far out into the lane. And the number of lanes also changes - two lane roads often become one lane, either due to lack of room between the snow piles or because drivers on some roads spontaneously form a single file down center of what used to be two lanes.


Change is a crucial factor to consider in any long-lived system. Douglas Adams had a few words about it in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.

It's relatively easy to create a first-time-through map of something. You simply record everything you see (or thought you saw). On revisiting, there are now questions of:

• Was that here the first time?

• Did it move? Was it mismeasured?

• What about the stuff that's recorded that we don't see?

Early cartogrophers (as well as researchers in conceptual fields) often mistakenly create or record features where none actually exist (or at least no subsequent evidence is found). Often the ghosts of these features haunt maps (or textbooks) for centuries.

Essentially, you need a map, ultimately, which has a sense for the permanence of any highway feature, and to not fall prey to map-territory relation assertion fallacies: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Map-territory_relation

The map is not the territory.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: