Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

He should have released it as a torrent. The whole damn thing.

There are too many motherfucking secrets.



There are a few advantages to releasing a stream rather than a torrent.

First, it keeps the story going. Had it been a single torrent, there would have been a lot of stories, and then on to the next thing. That this may also be more commercially successful does not escape me.

Second, it give the government a chance to really put their foot in their mouths. With Wikileaks, the US mostly said nothing about the details. With the Snowden documents, government officials respond to one thing, then further documents reveal where they are lying or weaseling.

Third, once the torrent is done, the government can do a whitewash investigation, and then say "all that is behind us. We've fixed the problems and now we're focusing on the future." It's not possible to have a whitewash investigation unless you know all that needs to be covered.

Fourth, this is a complex issue, and the process of reporting lets the reporters have time to get feedback from the analysis of other people, and integrate new information into their reporting.

Of these, I think #3 is the most important advantage to a stream over a torrent.


Great points, but I think #1 is the most important for affecting change (although #2 is the most entertaining). Keeping government shenanigans in the top of the news cycle means that elected officials are constantly under pressure to actually do something about it.


Very good points. A valid option would have been to release a torrent of encrypted files and then slowly release ways to decrypt the files one at a time.

This way the information is out there but only gets revealed a little at a time.


well said!


That'd make it much easier to portray them as irresponsible risks to national security. They're trying, but the caution and deliberation being used in these releases counts heavily in the favor of the news orgs.


I wouldn't be surprised if these files contain an encrypted copy of Snowden's files http://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2013/08/20/whats-wikileaks-h...


Because your life is on the line, you don't care. Way to put yourself above Governments by caring less about life than them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: