Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The collectivist/individualist conflict in this article is odd. On the one hand, she seems to be opposed to collective responsibility:

Men supporting the notion that their female significant other can contribute as an equal partner financially or be the bread-winner of the household....leaving the choice of taking care of elderly parents up to women.

Ok, sounds good. No one owes anyone anything, you can do as you like with your life. No social obligations.

Having supportive social and economic practices for those who do chose to have children and take care of aging family members, which will need to be reinforced by some body such as companies or governments.

Wait what? So non-mothers owe mothers "support", socially and economically?

I'd love to know the philosophical underpinnings of this odd combination of individualism and collectivism. I do hope it's something more interesting than simply "the universe should make my chosen lifestyle easier!"

(Incidentally, it's incoherent articles like this one which have convinced me that more people should learn philosophy. I describe it as incoherent simply because it has a gaping philosophical hole, and no attempt whatsoever is made to explain it.)



I don't think it's incoherent. The argument about women being free to make a choice about having children does not preclude a partner from having a part in that choice. It is about freedom from societal pressures, not freedom from a partner. The fourth point then says that if the couple chooses to have a child, it should be considere normal by society that the partner contributes equally to the burden of having a child.


She's not advocating for division of parental responsibilities to be a private matter between parents and child, she's advocating for non-mothers to support mothers:

...supportive social and economic practices for those who do chose to have children...need to be reinforced by some body such as companies or governments.


As we are usually all children, workers, and aging family members at some point, but the responsibility of childbirth, child-rearing, and elder care are, due to biology and historical discrimination, largely and/or completely borne by a subset of half of the population, the justification seems pretty obvious on its face.

Just because it includes collective reasoning and is not libertarian doesn't make it self-contradicting.


The justification is not obvious to me. Could you explain in careful detail?

Please start by listing any necessary moral premises. For example, collective guilt, individual freedom, and how to determine which collectives these principles apply to (assuming of course that these principles are what underlies your position). In the US there are 2^{300 million} possible collectives, but you seem to have it narrowed down to 1. How?

I didn't claim that it was self contradicting because it was non-libertarian. I claimed that it seemed contradictory without further explanation because early on she appeals to individualism (when it benefits women making her particular life choices) but later on appeals to collective responsibility (when it benefits women making her particular life choices).

There might be some consistent underlying principle and it might not be contradictory. I just can't figure out what it is, which is why I asked the question.


Subsidies to mothers are already massive.

For example: Free k-12 school. That's a $3-10k/year subsidy right there (taxpayers spend $11,073 on this $3k-$10k subsidy - what a deal!).

Another example: Many states require paid maternity leave (is this Federal now?). That's a pretty massive subsidy!

Another example: We do have super high rates of child support in the Anglosphere, you know. Look to France & others for more sane approaches to this subject and more sane rates. (France & sane? I'm serious!).

Where does this all end? What level of subsidization is sufficient?

I bet someone even responds to me with a 'for the children' comment. You watch.


This is one of the most absurd comments I've ever read.

How is free K-12 a subsidy to mothers? If anything, public education is a huge subsidy to employers.

Also, child support mandates in the U.S. are not high and in many cases don't come close to covering half the costs of child rearing.

Say the father makes $45,000/year (far above the national median individual income). His net income is Illinois is around $2,700 per month. His child support obligation is $540/month. That's $6,500 per year, or about half the annual average cost of raising a child in the urban midwest according to this calculator: http://money.cnn.com/interactive/pf/cost-of-children/?iid=EL.

That level is already a huge subsidy from the mother to the father. The mother and father pay half the expenses of raising the child, but on top of that the mother takes on all of the domestic work necessary to raise the kid, and also shoulders the full career hit that comes from having childcare responsibilities. As someone who has tried to outsource a lot of domestic childcare duties, let me say that the market value of the domestic labor provided solely by the mother in this example far outweighs the total income of the median male.


Reality check: Outside of the Anglosphere, child support often tops out around a few hundred dollars/month. The average support level in France is ~$160/mo.

How do those poor French mothers survive?

>If anything, public education is a huge subsidy to employers.

If left to their own devices, I doubt employers would choose to spend $11k/yr/pupil on fingerpainting and remedial math.


Nobody has ever given a shit about what the French think. A child is the product of a father and a mother. When parents don't stay together, the only logical way to divide the burden of raising a child is to allocate 50% of the monetary expenses and 50% of the labor to each parent. Anything that allocates less than this to fathers is a huge subsidy from women to men.

As for employers, finger-painting is pre-K, which isn't universally free in the states. Starting in Kindergarten, education starts with basic literacy. The production of a literate and numerate workforce is a huge subsidy to employers. The crack about remedial math actually undermines your position: its remedial math that creates the huge population of people who have enough basic numeracy to operate a cash register, thus driving the cost of cashiers down to almost nothing. Also, the high supply of literate and numerate labor drives down the wages of each marginal employee, allowing employers to capture a higher percentage of the value generated by the employee. If an employer makes $25 per hour off of someone he pays $10, and public education makes that person employable, then right there the employer benefits mord from education than the employee. Finally, remember that in the states education is funded by property taxes, which are largely paid for by families and not businesses. So families pay most of that $11k per year, not businesses.

And leaving aside the benefit to employers, why do you call K12 a subsidy to mothers, rather than both fathers and mothers equally?


The crack was about it costing $11k/yr, not that remedial math is bad.


It's almost as if France has a robust social safety net. Child support just might be less. if we had things like:

1) inexpensive municipal day care

2) tax breaks for families employing in-home child care workers

3) universal free preschool beginning at age 3.

As to your last point I'm assuming you're implying that all women learn in K-12 is painting fingernails and remedial math, in which case, fuck you.


You don't know what fingerpainting is :(

Re: Social safety net:

That's why child support stops after the child turns three? (that's a joke for those who don't know it continues to 18)


Oh duh, finger painting, gotcha, my mistake. Why do you say remedial math though?

Why would child support stop at 3 just because there's free preschool? You still have to provide all the other necessities of life like, you know, food and clothing.


I don't think you know anything about paid maternity leave in this country as compared to the rest of the world: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/04/maternity-leave-pai...


If philosophy teaches you that ideas need to fit in one of binary opposite buckets, that sounds like an argument for not studying it.


Studying philosophy teaches that questions like this need to be answered (or at least acknowledged) rather than ignored.


> I do hope it's something more interesting than simply "the universe should make my chosen lifestyle easier!"

That's all it is, as long as that lifestyle is staying home and having kids. Otherwise you're a selfish bitch and looked down upon.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: