Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Well, much depends on exactly what sort of car you're buying and when you're buying it, too.

I bought my first car in 2006. It was a GM product, about a year old, and with about 12,000 miles on it. I paid just over half of what it would have cost to buy it new. That was a good deal.

I bought a new car this past summer from Toyota. I would have saved a couple of thousand dollars going used, which just wasn't worth it to me compared to getting something with a known provenance. The price difference wasn't very big, in any case.

Between the brand (GMs depreciate like mad, Toyotas not so much) and the economic climate (I get the impression that Cash for Clunkers took a lot of used cars off the road, and demand for used cars is higher in a weaker economy anyway), the difference between the two cases was massive.



I bought a Lincoln LS in Dubai, UAE for $22100 from the ford dealer with 300 miles on it in 2007 (2006 MY); it was $45k list price. There were 8 in country and it had just been cancelled. Extra bonus is I found a $1k satellite phone under the seat.


I found the same thing with Toyotas when I was shopping for a new SUV a few years back. I was open to buying used but the savings I saw just weren't worth it to me relative to buying new--especially given that the dealer came down to pretty much invoice.

Ref: parent post. The situation if you do your own maintenance and/or have a good independent mechanic for your brand can certainly change the equation. For example, I've been told that high-end car (Mercedes, BMW, etc.) maintenance, including scheduled maintenance, gets really expensive after the warranty period so you probably don't want to buy a used one if your idea of dealing with a car is dropping it off at the dealer as needed. It's also a question of how tolerant you are of dealing with car repairs generally as opposed to just owning something that gets you reliably and comfortably from Point A to B with a minimum of service overhead.


Cash for Clunkers wasn't so big a program (regardless of its merits), and the mpg requirement means that it didn't hit sedans and small cars that much.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: