Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What do you mean by "decent professors"? If you mean "quality teachers", then you'll have a very easy time of it. There is a huge oversupply of PhD's, and many are excellent teachers. You can get good teachers quite cheaply.

Accredition and reputation are the main barriers.



There is a huge oversupply of PhD's, and many are excellent teachers.

Agreeing with your first point that there are lots of Ph.D.s to go around to staff many colleges, how does one check your second point that a particular person is a good teacher? What is the best evidence for determining who is an effective teacher at the college level, and how is that evidence gathered at each college where Ph.D.s teach, and used at each college that has occasion to hire new faculty?


Disclaimer: most of what I'm about to say is second hand info. I'm a research postdoc, so teaching matters very little to me (all I need to do is show up). However, I know several people who did go through this process.

Current method: student evaluation. Treat it as a roughly equal mix of easiness, sympathy (1), clarity and charisma.

The best method would be to measure outcomes on standardized exams. However, in all cases I've seen, the teacher doesn't affect this very much. Very few places do this.

In practice, most teaching colleges hire mainly based on personal connections or random chance (whoever applied at the right time). So I didn't mean to imply that new entrants into the college market could do a good job of hiring teachers. Basically, they can do just as good a job as anyone else.

(1) Fun fact: my teaching evaluations went down about 40% after I stopped acting sympathetic and started writing my own tests.

"Sorry the test is so hard, I didn't write it. I'll try to help you pass it and see what I can do about a curve." -> good evaluations.

"Stop whining, i'll curve it if it's too hard. And yes, I do expect you to understand the concepts rather than just do mindless calculations." -> bad evaluations.

I could probably try harder to game the system, but I don't really want an academic job anymore.


you could control the standardized tests for IQ, which would cancel out noise. The problem is that you now need to administer two tests, and the errors implicit in assigning raw numbers to such fuzzy concepts as teaching ability multiply.


My experience is that not every PhD obtained one to become a teacher. In fact, most of them teach due to the requirements of the university (during their almost-PhD years), as opposed to any burning desire to shape the next generation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: