The problem is that this sort of reasoning poisons every topic. The reason for bringing up Al Awlaki is basically to say: "if the US government is murdering Americans in cold blood, what wont't they do?" And at that point debate is pointless. Okay, the rule of law is dead, let's move to Canada before we get drone striked for speaking ill of Obama.
Indeed, but you aren't going to convince ceejayoz on this matter. It isn't ceejayoz who you want to win over in this fight either, if he's already lost faith in the rule of law, then it is pointless to try and convince him to do something productive with the rule of law.
Do you want to get work done? Do you want to see legal change in America? Well, the way to step forward has already presented itself. Lets work forward, instead of focusing on tangential issues. I've pointed out the Senators who to support, and I've introduced the basic lay of the political field.
Focusing on literally dead-horse issues like Anwar Al-Awlaki will hamper progress. There is a single, clear, resounding message that can be brought to light here. Champion Wyden and Udall and amplify their message.
PS: Wyden and Udall have been critical of the Drones program as well.
"Focusing on literally dead-horse issues like Anwar Al-Awlaki will hamper progress."
The "literally" there - and the stressing of it - is rhetoric not argument. If Obama started assassinating anyone who disagreed, they'd be literally dead too, but addressing it would be a priority...