Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There is a lot of hate here for the "vigilantes" who singled him out. In no way do I approve of the subreddit devoted to finding these people, but I think many of the comments here blow what happened out of proportion.

No one arrested him, fired him, threatened him, or tried to hurt him. Even to a kid, I can't imagine this impacting your life too much. If he were traumatized, he'd not be allowing everyone to use his name.

Again, I don't approve of this kind of speculation, but they always labeled their work as speculation and discouraged people from acting on it. I think we might just be over-reacting.



> "No one arrested him, fired him, threatened him, or tried to hurt him."

Citation needed... Far tamer acts have elicited all of the above when put in front of the Internet Hate Machine (which now includes Reddit).

Remember Adria Richards? Yeah, she didn't kill anyone and she still got direct threats of being raped and killed.

The individual here hasn't been arrested or fired, but you can bet your ass he has been threatened and intimidated in ways neither of us can even imagine. The level of cruelty internet strangers have repeatedly demonstrated to others can best be described as "unquantifiably high".

> "Again, I don't approve of this kind of speculation, but they always labeled their work as speculation and discouraged people from acting on it."

This is a cop-out, and has about as much legitimacy as those "no copyright infringement intended" descriptions under pirated YouTube videos.


>labeled their work as speculation

AKA the "No offense, but..." of Internet witch-hunts.


For accuracy, it looks like they did receive threats. Apparently from a friend of his on Reddit.

"the 2 guys been getting shit of calls, and they are scared like hell"

http://www.reddit.com/r/findbostonbombers/comments/1cjghc/4c...




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: