Why couldn't we follow a different path to reform from that proposed by the Swarthmore psychology professor and have all applicants to some "top" group of colleges submit a rank-ordered list of their preferred colleges to a central matching organization, to which colleges would also submit a rank-ordered list of applicants? That is already done for medical residency programs in the United States after graduation from medical school,
I think bright high school students on their way to top colleges could figure out their preferences well enough to deal with such a system, and the colleges ought to be able to deal with it too.
It's an interesting idea, but you have to be careful about these mathematical proofs of optimality.
First of all, it is very hard to rank the schools before seeing the offers, visiting the campuses, doing more thorough research (which you may not have as much time to do while preparing your applications).
Second of all, there are other factors involved. Where did your friends and boyfriend/girlfriend get in to? This is one big problem of the medical placement system, especially for those who are married by then.
Where did your friends and boyfriend/girlfriend get in to?
Yes, the mathematical proof of optimality only applies to one snapshot of time. Having exactly one choice of college after a date certain is a feature of any admission system, but there is considerable argument for that date certain being as late as possible.
Social welfare mechanisms like this are optimal in the utilitarian sense, but that's no consolation to those who get the short end of the stick. If the system doesn't leave everyone better off then it's not unquestionably superior to the status quo.
http://www.nrmp.org/
and it is provable mathematically that the match algorithm offers the optimal trade-off among the different preferences of applicants and programs.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stable_marriage_problem
http://www.cs.columbia.edu/~evs/intro/stable/
I think bright high school students on their way to top colleges could figure out their preferences well enough to deal with such a system, and the colleges ought to be able to deal with it too.