Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Whatever your opinion of the software, you have to admit this is a really good ad. It hits Apple where it hurts, and given the timing, it hurts more than ever.


"you have to admit this is a really good ad"

I don't. It not only refers to the competition by name, it clearly says that when given the opportunity to buy any computer, a person's first reaction is to visit the competition's store. It refers to the competition's computers as cool. It argues the only reason to buy a PC is if you don't have enough money to buy a Mac. Apple would agree whole heartedly with this ad. It essentially does their job for them.

"It hits Apple where it hurts"

How? By preaching to a market segment Apple doesn't even compete in? I don't think they'll be loosing any sleep (or sales).

"given the timing, it hurts more than ever"

What timing? Why would it hurt more? Your vague cliches have befuddled me.


I agree with your above statements. However, referring to the competition by name isn't always a bad thing. Many companies do it to great success. Direct comparisons are great in advertising and they are trying to draw a direct comparison though potentially failing here. It will be interesting to see how the campaign does.


I was referring to economic timing, if it wasn't clear. People have less spare cash than ever. Even Apple fans.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: