Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There was a fun observation in American science that the effect of lead on IQ seems to have gotten worse over time.

The postulated mechanism is:

1. Some places have lead, and suck.

2. Because they suck, they are inhabited by people without better options.

3. Those people are stupid.

4. You can do a study comparing the IQs of people in relatively high-lead environments and other people, and, if you attribute the entire difference to lead exposure, you'll see that lead has a negative effect on IQ, which you can represent in terms of IQ points per hair ppm or whatever unit you want.

5. If you then mount a big effort to rehabilitate those environments to clean out the lead, they'll have less lead. Still more than usual, but not as much as before. Lead exposure in the people who live there will fall.

6. But those environments are still bad (if not quite as bad) and the people there are still stupid.

7. If you rerun your study from step 4, you'll observe that people in high-lead areas are still dumber than people in low-lead areas, by about the same amount as the earlier study found.

8. But, the high-lead areas have less lead now than they did then.

9. Attributing the entire IQ deficit to lead exposure, we logically find that each unit of lead exposure is now much more harmful than the earlier study found. There's a lot less lead, but the deficit is just as bad - this means that the effect of the lead got worse!

 help



>2. Because they suck, they are inhabited by people without better options.

This is true for everything else related to housing issues, not just lead. Areas with more air and noise pollution, more crime, etc. remain inhabited by those who can't do better to afford to leave and move out, and only the poor who can't do better remain stuck there.


> more crime ... the poor who can't do better

Does crime cause poverty, or does poverty cause crime?


White collar crime, especially corporate wage theft, is worse for society and by extension causes both.

Let me postulate a different question : does poverty without wealth inequality correlate with crime ?

Both. Which business owner would invest in a poor high crime area? Which skilled ambitious employees are left to work in any potential new business investment were to happen in a high crime are? It's a continuous chicken and egg problem that's self sustaining.

Can it not be both?



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: