Plan on "processing" stuff decades ago. Cut budgets to save money today, it takes longer to process. Stuff sits around instead of being "processed" inevitably causing a vastly larger environmental disaster and vastly higher total costs. If we cut the processing budget even more to generate oversight reports that won't be read and will suggest the only safe path is to spend more money quicker, we'll instead spend less money slower because we'll spend the money on oversight and reports.
Taking money out of the processing budget to hire a bunch of people to generate reports saying we should process more is counterproductive.
The morally/ethically best thing the oversight department could recommend is its own dissolution, which is a big ask for humans with kids and bills and mortgages to pay.
A good analogy of the problem is Detroit spends about $6M/yr on lead abatement. I'm sure some percentage is fraudulent (it's Detroit, so maybe 20%?) and some sites that should be abated are not cleaned "in time" to prevent medical problems for the locals. The obvious solution is to create a $5M/yr oversight committee to carefully audit the lead abatement program. However, gutting $5M out of the $6M abatement program to audit the program would be quite counterproductive. Also its unimaginable the audit program would be less corrupt than the people currently working, so the savings would be quite low, and its unimaginable the audit program would recommend anything other than spending money on abatement. So creating the audit program would inevitably result in a worse outcome given fixed resources.
You could argue they need to get more money from the budget. However if they use the money for hiring expensive auditors not abatement, the general public is worse off.
There also is a lack of evidence that there is no auditing or incompetent auditing.
We already have an infinite pile of EPA documents basically stating, "its messed up and no one has the budget to fix it" so no one can explain why making the pile larger would help or spending money on making the pile of documents larger rather than fixing what problems they can would help.
No one wants to hear that we already have a list of expensive unfixable ignored problems, its preferable to think we don't have any problems at all so lets spend money on creating a list.
Taking money out of the processing budget to hire a bunch of people to generate reports saying we should process more is counterproductive.
The morally/ethically best thing the oversight department could recommend is its own dissolution, which is a big ask for humans with kids and bills and mortgages to pay.
A good analogy of the problem is Detroit spends about $6M/yr on lead abatement. I'm sure some percentage is fraudulent (it's Detroit, so maybe 20%?) and some sites that should be abated are not cleaned "in time" to prevent medical problems for the locals. The obvious solution is to create a $5M/yr oversight committee to carefully audit the lead abatement program. However, gutting $5M out of the $6M abatement program to audit the program would be quite counterproductive. Also its unimaginable the audit program would be less corrupt than the people currently working, so the savings would be quite low, and its unimaginable the audit program would recommend anything other than spending money on abatement. So creating the audit program would inevitably result in a worse outcome given fixed resources.
You could argue they need to get more money from the budget. However if they use the money for hiring expensive auditors not abatement, the general public is worse off.
There also is a lack of evidence that there is no auditing or incompetent auditing.
We already have an infinite pile of EPA documents basically stating, "its messed up and no one has the budget to fix it" so no one can explain why making the pile larger would help or spending money on making the pile of documents larger rather than fixing what problems they can would help.
No one wants to hear that we already have a list of expensive unfixable ignored problems, its preferable to think we don't have any problems at all so lets spend money on creating a list.