Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Ditch diggers do not lament a shovel. Astronauts cannot circle the world without reliance on a host of industries, machines, computers, and software they could barely enumerate much less replace.

Why is this lever different?

 help



Machines such as excavators substitute for human labor. The more excavators you have, the fewer ditch diggers you want. But machines are also complements to labor. The more excavators you have, the more excavator operators you want. That's how, despite machines making earlier jobs obsolete, people have still managed to collect wages from their labor.

Machine intelligence is different because it fully substitutes for human cognition. Similar to chess engines, at some point AI will get good enough that any human input is just adding noise. And the cost to run such machines will be much lower than the cost to feed, clothe, shelter, and educate a human. This means that almost everyone will be forced to retire, and they'll have to live off investments, or get government welfare from taxes on machines.

On the bright side, if economic growth is no longer limited by the number of people and their capabilities, we should see very high economic growth rates. That means it won't take much investment for a person to be able to afford a high quality of life indefinitely. Though all of this assumes that the machines will care about people (or at least obey laws made by people). If that's not the case, then humanity would most likely go extinct.


> This means that almost everyone will be forced to retire, and they'll have to live off investments, or get government welfare from taxes on machines.

You're assuming a form of utopia with unlimited resources.

At the other end of the spectrum, we can just as well imagine governments (human or automatized) deciding that some categories of people are obsolete and should be simply... phased away.


Not a utopia with unlimited resources, just much richer than our world, similar to how we're richer than people from before the industrial revolution. There would still be positional goods such as status symbols and proximity to famous/desirable places.

The "governments killing unproductive people" argument doesn't make sense to me. We already have large classes of "obsolete" people such as retirees and the disabled. No sane person suggests killing them (or even just taking their wealth) so that the economy can be steered toward more productive purposes. Doing so would create enough chaos that productive people would wonder, "Who's next?"


> Machine intelligence is different because it fully substitutes for human cognition.

This has not been my experience. In fact, they are much like levers. I can do really useful things with them, because I know my area or I can learn where needed (also AIDED by LLMs), but somebody with zero SWE experience and zero domain knowledge will simply not be able to get anywhere.


I thought it was clear from the sentences after the one you quoted that I was talking about future AIs, not current ones. But unless you think AI progress will soon grind to a halt, you should expect cheap full substitutes for human cognition in your lifetime, and probably before you plan to retire.

Remember that the first release of ChatGPT was only 4 years ago. Consider how quickly AI has advanced, and how there's been no noticeable slowdown in new capabilities (if anything I think it's accelerated). I'm investing more of my money instead of spending it on fun stuff, as I'd like for my family to live comfortably if I'm forced to retire early. If AI stagnates for the next couple decades, I miss out on some fun (no Cessna 172 for me). But if progress continues, I'm better prepared.


This is where I am at as well.

Do I think we are headed for a time when the junior talent will simply dry up and seek employment elsewhere? Leading to an industry-wide gap in ability? Yeah, unless FAANG et al do something about it. And they're not famous for taking the long term view of things.


Ditch diggers do not generally enjoy ditch digging?

In general, if you did X for the outcomes, AI is nice. If you liked X for the process, AI sucks.


I was in it for both, and I'm still enjoying the process.

It’s so bizarre that tech folks like comparing intelligence and decision-making to ditch-digging.

Really? You don’t see the obvious difference?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: