> President Dwight D. Eisenhower expressed his belief that every child should receive the polio vaccine, without indicating how that would happen. Eisenhower charged Health, Education and Welfare Secretary Ovetta Culp Hobby to work out the details in coordination with Surgeon General Leonard Scheele.
> Congressional Democrats advocated for a plan that would make the polio vaccine free to everyone, which Hobby rejected as a “back door to socialized medicine.”
Yes, there are a lot of other details in the history of the polio vaccine, but I fail to see for this isn't exactly what I described. The person in Eisenhower's cabinet who he put in charge of figuring this out used those words in the context I described. The fact that it was preceded by "back door to" is only as "complicated and nuanced" as the understanding that a back door still leads to the same house as the front door.
>Yes, there are a lot of other details in the history of the polio vaccine, but I fail to see for this isn't exactly what I described. The person in Eisenhower's cabinet who he put in charge of figuring this out used those words in the context I described. The fact that it was preceded by "back door to" is only as "complicated and nuanced" as the understanding that a back door still leads to the same house as the front door.
You're leaving out the part where Eisenhower requested USD$28,000,000 from Congress to purchase vaccine for free distribution to American children (from Eisenhower's 1955 "Statement to the Nation")[0]:
To assist the States in providing free vaccinations, I have recommended that
the Congress enact legislation making $28 million available to the States for
the purchase of vaccine. This legislation is now being considered by the
appropriate Committees of the Congress and I urge its immediate adoption.
Congress responded by passing a bill funding his request to the tune of USD$30,000,000. Eisenhower then signed that bill into law[1]:
Eisenhower then signed the Polio Vaccination Assistance Act of 1955, which
slated $30 million to pay for vaccines – enough to fund wider public
distribution. Within a year, 30 million American kids had been inoculated,
and the number of polio cases had fallen almost by half.
So yes, the Eisenhower Administration did push back. And then, for a variety of reasons, changed course and supported Federal funding of vaccines. Which is, as I said, more complex and nuanced than '...the Eisenhower administration tried to resist giving the vaccine out for free because it was "socialized medicine".'
That's one part of the story. Why do you insist on ignoring the other parts of that same story?
I didn't said "insisted on not providing the vaccine for free". I said "tried to resist", which implies that they acquiesced. Why do you insist that this is not an accurate picture?
>I didn't said "insisted on not providing the vaccine for free". I said "tried to resist", which implies that they acquiesced.
I never suggested anything like that. I asserted that your initial claim was over simplified, not that it was incorrect. More complex and nuanced means that there's more to the story, not that what you said was untrue.
It absolutely was part of the truth. The rest of the story, which you declined to include or acknowledge, made your assertion incomplete rather than incorrect.
You'll note that I said:
So yes, the Eisenhower Administration did push back. And then, for a variety
of reasons, changed course and supported Federal funding of vaccines. Which
is, as I said, more complex and nuanced than '...the Eisenhower
administration tried to resist giving the vaccine out for free because it was
"socialized medicine".'
Where did I say your statement was inaccurate? I strongly implied that it wasn't the whole story (when I said that "Like most things, the story is more complicated and nuanced[0][1][2] than that.")
I most certainly did not say your statement was wrong. I asserted that it was incomplete. See the difference?
And when you quoted a section from one of the links I shared that supported your initial, incomplete assertion, I agreed with you and then filled out other parts of the story (some of which were included in the link you quoted) that your initial statement and further writing did not address.
That's one part of the story. Why do you insist on ignoring the other parts of that same story?
Nowhere did I claim that your initial statement was untrue. It absolutely is true. But it's just one part (and IMNSHO, not an important part, given the outcome) of the story of the US Government's (both the Executive and Legislative branches) response and support for distribution of the Polio vaccine.
>Why do you insist that this is not an accurate picture?
I didn't insist on anything of the kind. I said:
That's one part of the story. Why do you insist on
ignoring the other parts of that same story?
Which asserts that you are focusing only on a single part of the story and ignoring the rest of the story.
We appear to be in violent agreement here. If I haven't made myself clear, then it's unlikely I will. In which case, my apologies for not being able to communicate more effectively.
> President Dwight D. Eisenhower expressed his belief that every child should receive the polio vaccine, without indicating how that would happen. Eisenhower charged Health, Education and Welfare Secretary Ovetta Culp Hobby to work out the details in coordination with Surgeon General Leonard Scheele.
> Congressional Democrats advocated for a plan that would make the polio vaccine free to everyone, which Hobby rejected as a “back door to socialized medicine.”
Yes, there are a lot of other details in the history of the polio vaccine, but I fail to see for this isn't exactly what I described. The person in Eisenhower's cabinet who he put in charge of figuring this out used those words in the context I described. The fact that it was preceded by "back door to" is only as "complicated and nuanced" as the understanding that a back door still leads to the same house as the front door.