In your comment to which I replied, you also said this:
> If your growth doesn't compete with other places they could invest their money, why shouldn't they take it back?
You used the word "should". That is moving it from descriptive to prescriptive. If it is purely descriptive, there is no such notion as what someone "should" do.
You also said:
> People say this and act like it has something to do with greed. No.
But insofar as economics is a descriptive science in the way you suggest, if it doesn't say that greed was a motivating factor, it also cannot say that it wasn't a motivating factor. From a descriptive perspective, motivations and morally weighted terms like "greed" are neither here nor there.
Hence even if we assume economics is descriptive, it still makes perfect sense to examine the background conditions that serve as input to economic situations, and devise ways to change them so that the economic "outputs" change. This is akin to studying how a particular kind of wood holds up in different environmental conditions, and using that to make a decision about whether to replace it with a different kind of wood, or a different material altogether (like metal).
Such a decision is "out of band" in the sense that if we say we were originally thinking about "oak science", then replacing the oak with steel is not part of "oak science". But if we say we were thinking about "building science", then both are in bounds. Similarly, it is absurd to claim that human motivations such as greed, and our moral feelings about them, do not play a meaningful role in human societies, including the economic behavior of individuals in those societies. We can declare greed not part of economics, which just means economics doesn't tell us everything we want to know; or we can declare it part of economics.
But it doesn't really matter, because the purpose of this kind of thinking is not to win points in some kind of economics-internal debate, but to make the world better. So to return to your original quote above about "Why shouldn't they take it back": they shouldn't take it back if it is bad to do so. It doesn't matter whether calling it bad is part of economics or not; it's still fine for people to set up society to prevent people from doing things they think are bad.
> If your growth doesn't compete with other places they could invest their money, why shouldn't they take it back?
You used the word "should". That is moving it from descriptive to prescriptive. If it is purely descriptive, there is no such notion as what someone "should" do.
You also said:
> People say this and act like it has something to do with greed. No.
But insofar as economics is a descriptive science in the way you suggest, if it doesn't say that greed was a motivating factor, it also cannot say that it wasn't a motivating factor. From a descriptive perspective, motivations and morally weighted terms like "greed" are neither here nor there.
Hence even if we assume economics is descriptive, it still makes perfect sense to examine the background conditions that serve as input to economic situations, and devise ways to change them so that the economic "outputs" change. This is akin to studying how a particular kind of wood holds up in different environmental conditions, and using that to make a decision about whether to replace it with a different kind of wood, or a different material altogether (like metal).
Such a decision is "out of band" in the sense that if we say we were originally thinking about "oak science", then replacing the oak with steel is not part of "oak science". But if we say we were thinking about "building science", then both are in bounds. Similarly, it is absurd to claim that human motivations such as greed, and our moral feelings about them, do not play a meaningful role in human societies, including the economic behavior of individuals in those societies. We can declare greed not part of economics, which just means economics doesn't tell us everything we want to know; or we can declare it part of economics.
But it doesn't really matter, because the purpose of this kind of thinking is not to win points in some kind of economics-internal debate, but to make the world better. So to return to your original quote above about "Why shouldn't they take it back": they shouldn't take it back if it is bad to do so. It doesn't matter whether calling it bad is part of economics or not; it's still fine for people to set up society to prevent people from doing things they think are bad.