Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Chamberlain actively fights all attempts at third parties buildnig tools to control/monitor/use their garage door openers so they can sell subscriptions.

Giving them money in the first place is a horrible idea.

 help



I wonder why they spend the effort. It seems like the people willing to pay and people willing to hack are different. With the hackers be a small group anyway

They don't want someone to sell an add-on product that fixes it?

Every garage door opener should allow a wired button. That is all you need to control it with any 3rd party or diy system.

True, although that - by itself - will not give the garage door status.

Most 3rd party systems also come with a magnetic sensor that you install on the door, to get door status.

Same reason any other company lawyers up when a handful of nerds modify the hardware they bought and own - it gets some suity dude's nose out of joint.

They're asking for legislation to address their predatory practices about as hard as you can. If I buy a garage door opener I should own access to it without the bullshit.

Had to get a new garage door opener because the old one stopped working. Got a MyQ opener because it seemed like an excellent choice. Now my car wants me to pay for a subscription to open the door and the remotes that came with the damn thing have super-short range.

On top of that I live less than a mile from an airport directly in the descent path so there is basically 0 mobile service at my home. Often the MyQ app fails to function at all.

My old garage door opener got the damn thing open every time without issue. Would love to have it back.


If your vehicle has HomeLink or can get it installed it should work with even the new MyQ garage openers. I had one installed on my Tesla for my garage opener.

Yeah I was a bit unhappy to see that I can open my MQ remotely via their native app, but if I want my Tesla to do the same thing I have to opt into MQ premium subscription.


I did the first one. AFAIK it doesn't quite work with all garage door openers because they started using special switches that don't just close the circuit.


And if you want to make your own, there's rat-ratgdo https://github.com/Kaldek/rat-ratgdo - got one on a breadboard and it works perfectly.

Sometimes you get what the installer has in stock, I didn’t really “pick” Chamberlain, it’s just what the guy put in when I paid him to “fix my garage door”. For a lot of other people it’s just what comes with the house.

The correct answer is to just let your garage door opener be dumb, and buy a RatGDO, which works with any dumb opener including chamberlains: https://ratcloud.llc/

I like to think chamberlain sells their openers at a slightly lower price than they otherwise would, hoping to recover it on subscriptions. So by buying their opener plus a RatGDO, I’m hurting their bottom line just a tiny amount. It makes me feel good at least.


Unfortunately Chamberlain Security + 3.0 openers are not supported. If I ever need to replace my current garage door opener I will be looking for a non-Chamberlain product.

https://ratcloud.llc/pages/frequently-asked-questions


Unfortunately new chamberlains now come with Security 3.0, which is designed to lock out ratgdo and everything else, probably forever. So you’re kind of screwed if you’ve bought one recently.

I never understand the appeal of RatGDO. You can find other tools like Shelly 1 that can be easily integrated into your existing Zigbee/Matter ecosystem, or part of the Home Assistant via the HTTP interface, and they are much cheaper with proper UL certification.

The appeal of RatGDO is the ability to look at my Home Assistant dashboard and see the exact metrics of my garage door, even when I'm not home. It really solves that "Did I forget to close the door when I left" scenario. I can also issue commands that set it to a specific state. If the door is closed, I can say "close the door" and nothing happens.

The Shelly works as a great remote "I pushed the button to toggle the door" device. But did the door actually close? What if the door was already closed, now I've just opened it, how would I know?

If your goal is to simply replace the remote that you would use and only operate the door while it is in line of sight, then the Shelly is fine. And if your use case doesn't ever leave you needing to operate the door out of line of sight, then that's great, but there are other use cases that do warrant being able to validate the current state of the door beyond just a button press toggle.


You don’t have to buy the expensive official ratgdo device. The ratgdo software is free and you can build a small PCB for a few bucks plus the cost of the ESP32 and a couple of components. My house unfortunately came with MyQ openers so that’s what I’m doing.

I tried to do exactly this last year, and found out that the Chamberlain security-2.0 openers do not accept a simple circuit closing as a signal to invoke the open/close mechanism. Even the wired buttons speak some kind of "secure" 1-wire protocol, hence why the ratgdo exists in the first place.

Do you have a link to instructions on how to do it with a simple Shelly relay?


I outright reject any garage door solution which doesn’t provide discrete “open” and “close” commands. This is not a hard ask.

Why did we ever think one button was acceptable? How is that the norm?


Because you have to be there to press the button.

Not if there’s a safety sensor installed on the door. Plenty of garage door motors have an “auto close” feature which doesn’t require your presence.

Which is a good idea anyway, with pets, children, valuables, etc.?

I mean it kinda depends. If for example you have a trusted friend stopping by and dropping something off when you weren't there you'd have to do a lot of coordination before hand to ensure they had a key or remote.

Now they call you, you open it up and close it when they are gone.

So, yea, I can see why more than a few people would want to do that.


for a long time, there have been keypads people attach near their garages with combo codes on them (enter the code to open the garage).

no cloud connectivity required. some of them even hardwire into the door opener!


No one time codes.

Typically easy to hack, especially when the numbers show wear.


Sure, but also requires physical access (so security cameras, etc.) and isn’t uploading all your shit to China. shrug

You can also get various devices that are essentially radio-controlled solenoids that can be used to push physical buttons. One example is this, https://shop.yosmart.com/products/ys4908. Now with that particular product you end up being tied into their cloud infrastructure, but there's others out there that don't do this.

You really have to be a special kind of person to try to sell subscriptions for things like garage door openers. I don't even completely understand why that would need to be online... so you can open your garage for half-way around the world? Do I need that?

Don't hate the player, hate the game. To be a business, you have to sell things people will buy.

You mean, make the game illegal via legislation because companies turn into rent seeking leaches that will do any number of immoral actions to enrich themselves.

"things" != "Services". They are innovating by removing product features and replacing them with paywall services. At some point, they will spend more r&d effort blocking paid customers from accessing paid features than improving their actual product.

And people are buying those things.

There are companies that didn't do this but they went bankrupt.


Any time a developer markets an app which “works when you’re not at home” the solution is always to run a small cloud and have your device and phone talk to some server run by the manufacturer which costs approximately $0.001 per customer per year to maintain.

there are no workarounds or options for their new security 3.0 models, you are just screwed. Their subscription or nothing. Just dont buy a Chamberlain/liftmaster.

Guess why this happened, to a brand with a previously stellar reputation? yep they got bought by PE.


In right-to-repair states, you likely have the option of demanding the ability to update that software. Check with the lawyer in your local state to see exactly what the law says and then get them to write the letter for asking for the keys so you can fix your garage door opener.

Something special about their "Security 3.0" models, or it's just that no one bothered to point a {Frontier as of 1-2 months ago, before excessive anti-RE guardrails} LLM at it yet?

Idk. But I’m not about to buy a product from a company that hates me and is hostile to me, just to try and crack it with an llm



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: