Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Biden didn't recognize it as a genocide either - and it was under his administration that the majority of the loss of life and property destruction happened. Or did the genocide to your judgement only start after Trump took office? Or is your point that all American leadership is fuckwits and you and your echochambers are smarter than everyone in charge?

> Only if they stay "exclusively focused on the wellbeing of Israeli arab communities", right? Per you?

That was poor phrasing on my part - obviously they can be focused on other things too, the underlying point is that Israeli Jews won't want them in coalitions so long as a major part of their party ethos is being against the mainline of what Israeli Jews consider to be necessary security measures.

Edit: just realized you misquoted me and I never wrote exclusively, I wrote relentlessly in the context of an imaginary party - still non-ideal phrasing but your misquote made it worse than it was.

 help



> Edit: just realized you misquoted me and I never wrote exclusively

Liar.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50542581

> If the Arab parties in Israel exclusively focused on the wellbeing of Israeli arab communities, and didn't function as a mouthpiece for what many Israelis consider to be the enemy - that 70 percent would go down significantly. Sure, it would never reach zero, like in any country there will always be racists and bigots, but it wouldn't be anywhere near as unanimous as it is right now.


Not a liar... just wrong. I didn't look all the way up in the thread, I only looked at the message directly above yours. My point regarding my poor phrasing stands.

So when you say my quote "made it worse than it was", and that quote turned out to be entirely accurate, did that prompt any self-reflection?

Are you kidding me? Yes, I wrote that writing "exclusively focused" was poor phrasing, softened it to non-ideal phrasing when I thought I was misquoted, and when I realized that I was accurately quoted I went back to saying that it was poor phrasing. What more do you want?

> What more do you want?

I want you to reflect on the fact that you thought the quote was bad enough you initially denied saying it when you had to read it back.

I wonder if that reflexive "no!" perhaps happens sometimes when reports come out about atrocities in Gaza.


This is a long thread stretching over several hours. You quoted me writing "exclusively focused", I looked one message above and saw I wrote "relentless focus on.." which is really similar phrasing so I thought you misquoted me, because I didn't remember the message I wrote hours ago and its phrasings. So I thought it was as simple as a misquote.

> I wonder if that reflexive "no!" perhaps happens sometimes when reports come out about atrocities in Gaza.

You know, many times I've thought about the difference between Holocaust denial and "Gaza genocide denial" as you might call it.

The difference is that while Holocaust deniers will outright deny scholarly consensus statistics, or in-your-face evidence of concentration camps, etc. most "Gaza genocide deniers" - don't deny the loss of life in Gaza, or even many war crimes committed by Israel, or the destruction, etc. There's no denial of most of the evidence. Sure, there are some fake stories out there, some with agendas, etc. - but the loss of life isn't under dispute.

The difference is whether or not the loss of life is attributable to Israel, or to Hamas - and the semantic argument of whether it constitutes genocide.


> most "Gaza genocide deniers" - don't deny the loss of life in Gaza… the loss of life isn't under dispute.

Liar, again. "Those are Hamas numbers!" was the talking point for years until the IDF quietly accepted them this year (https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2026-01-29/ty-article/.p...).

"Although many international experts have accepted the Health Ministry's data as reliable, and even conservative relative to the true death toll, Israel had refused to accept the Health Ministry's count until now."

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/jan/30/israel-militar...

"Israel’s military has accepted the death toll compiled by health authorities in Gaza is broadly accurate, marking a U-turn after years of official attacks on the data."

"For more than two years, Israeli officials and media had attacked the Palestinian figures as “Hamas propaganda” and dismissed them as “not accurate”."


I don't know what circles you spend your time in - I've been involved in many discussions across many forums both online and in real life, I've heard many pro-Israelis, pro-Palestinians, anti-Palestinians, etc. I've never heard anyone deny the loss of life in Gaza.

Yes, I've heard people cast doubt on the exact numbers reported by the Gaza Health Ministry (which is indeed Hamas-backed) - but it's doubt along the lines of "is the reported 30,000 dead actually 20,000 dead", not "is the reported 30,000 dead actually 200 dead". I've never seen the widespread extent of the loss of life challenged by anyone. And surely to your accusations of genocide, 20,000 and 30,000 are both genocidal, unless there's some strict numerical threshold?

Casting doubt on the source of the numbers themselves - is not equivalent to denying the loss of life. The IDF delaying acceptance of the Gaza Health Ministry’s numbers is not the same as "the IDF denying widespread loss of life in Gaza".


> I've never heard anyone deny the loss of life in Gaza.

I don't know what circles you spend your time in. It was the official position of the IDF and Israeli government for years.


If you find me one reliable source that shows the IDF or the Israeli government denying widespread loss of life in Gaza during this current war, I'll be willing to transfer you $10 in your cryptocurrency of choice.

And to be clear, a source that says "the IDF is denying Gaza Health Ministry numbers" is not the point here, I'm worried your poor reading comprehension might be rearing its head again.


https://www.npr.org/2024/07/25/nx-s1-5051749/fact-checking-n...

> In Netanyahu's speech to Congress yesterday, he described a recent visit to Rafah in southern Gaza. He said he asked a commander there how many civilians had been killed in Rafah since Israel began its offensive there in early May. And he said that commander told him...

> PRIME MINISTER BENJAMIN NETANYAHU: Practically none, with the exception of a single incident.


Poor reading comprehension again?

How is this equivalent to the denial of widespread loss of life in Gaza? Is the two months period between the start of the Rafah offensive - and Netanyahu's speech - inside of Rafah, representative of the whole war across Gaza?

I'm getting the impression there's no convincing you, you're so far gone inside propaganda and lies. Though I appreciate you taking the time to converse with me across this long thread, I don't think I'll be able to move the needle in your mind. You certainly haven't moved mine.


> How is this equivalent to the denial of widespread loss of life in Gaza?

To be clear, you're asking for concrete evidence of how Netanyahu demonstrably lying about civilian casualties is evidence that Netanyahu denies civilian casualties?


No. Netanyahu could be standing on the ground in Gaza, pointing at a dead body that was just killed, saying "no one was just killed in Gaza" - and it wouldn't address the point here.

Only if Netanyahu were to say something akin to "there has been no widespread loss of life in Gaza over this current war" - would that prove your point. And that hasn't happened.

And to be quite direct - this was phrased crystal clear in the challenge I gave you. You keep displaying poor reading comprehension which is ironic from someone who saw fit to call the American administration "fuckwits"


Guy, you lost your bet. You asked for evidence they denied deaths, you were given evidence they denied deaths. Now is the time to pay up.

> No. Netanyahu could be standing on the ground in Gaza, pointing at a dead body that was just killed, saying "no one was just killed in Gaza" - and it wouldn't address the point here.

So denying casualties doesn't count as evidence of a practice of denying casualties. Got it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Misinformation_in_the_Gaza_war

> In November 2023, Saleh al-Jafarawi, a Palestinian blogger and singer who lived in Gaza, was falsely accused by several pro-Israeli figures, including the country's official Twitter account, of being a "crisis actor".

> In the same month, Israeli diplomat Ofir Gendelman circulated a clip from a Lebanese short film, claiming that it was proof that Palestinians were faking their suffering and calling it an example of "Pallywood".

> The false claim was also promoted by others such as Israel's official Twitter account, Ben Shapiro, Hen Mazzig, Yoseph Haddad and StopAntisemitism.

> Also in August 2025, sociologist Ron Dudai analysed the widespread denial among Israelis of Israeli atrocities in the Gaza war as being a part of the longstanding Pallywood strategy, noting that while in earlier iterations it consisted of elaborate work to create conspiracy theories to deny atrocities as in the case of Muhammad Al-Durrah, in the Gaza War era, "the intricate conspiracy theories of the past have given way to a cruder form of denialism that scholars call conspiracism — the reflexive dismissal of any evidence that contradicts one's interests as fabricated. Documentation is simply dismissed with a single word: 'Fake'."

> In December 2023, an analysis by The Washington Post confirmed reports by Human Rights Watch that Israel had used white phosphorus in an attack on Lebanon, directly contradicting the IDF.

> n March 2025, Israel killed 15 paramedics from the Palestine Red Crescent Society and buried them in a mass grave along with their ambulances. The IDF initially claimed, "several vehicles were identified advancing suspiciously toward IDF troops without headlights, or emergency signals, their movement was not co-ordinated in advance. Thus, IDF troops opened fire at the suspected vehicles." However, after video evidence emerged showing the ambulances were clearly marked and using both headlights and flashing emergency lights, the IDF called their initial account "mistaken."

All just isolated incidents. The PM is just a smol bean who can't be held responsible for lies, and acts independently of the nation, having little power there.


Again, thanks for engaging with me and conversing across this long thread. I'll admit it added some interest to some dull moments of my day.

I would advise you - if you haven't already - to visit Israel and see it for yourself. Oftentimes when you "touch grass", so to speak, and leave the confines of your echo chambers and social media accounts and screens and propaganda - you might be surprised by what you find. Maybe not, there are plenty of visitors to Israel - or even native-born Israelis - who are decidedly anti-Israel. But still, worth a shot.


> I would advise you - if you haven't already - to visit Israel and see it for yourself.

People have tried that one. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/new-york-cong...

I wonder if you've taken this advice with regards to Gaza.


> I wonder if you've taken this advice with regards to Gaza.

Not to Gaza, but I've been to the West Bank. The first time indeed was to see it for myself, and it opened up my eyes to quite a few things.

If I visited Gaza I'd be slaughtered. If you visit Israel - unlikely that would happen to you.

> People have tried that one.

Well, I'll tell you what. How about your first visit to Israel, just for kicks - try to avoid clearly provocative actions. Just come and see things for yourself. You're highly unlikely to go through what Brad Lander went through.

I'm not saying what he went through was right or wrong - I think the entire situation could have been handled much better on Israel's side - but it's no reason not to visit if you don't have an agenda of provocative actions. If you do have such an agenda - maybe it's best not to visit, yeah.


> Not to Gaza, but I've been to the West Bank.

So, no.

Do you similarly think visiting early 1940s Berlin would've given me a bunch of insights into Auschwitz and the German people at the time? You're advising I go do some tourism in the safe confines of the occupying power.

"Come and see how nice we are to them!" is... not a new tactic. https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/theresiens...

> How about your first visit to Israel, just for kicks - try to avoid clearly provocative actions.

"Come, but don't dig too hard."

> I'm not saying what he went through was right or wrong

Maybe you should take a position.


> Do you similarly think visiting early 1940s Berlin would've given me a bunch of insights into Auschwitz and the German people at the time?

Not Auschwitz, but yes, it absolutely would have given you a bunch of insights into German people at the time..

> You're advising I go do some tourism in the safe confines of the occupying power.

Yes. Up to you, of course.

> Maybe you should take a position.

Maybe another day.

> "Come and see how nice we are to them!" is... not a new tactic.

Not what I said, not what I meant.


> Not Auschwitz, but yes, it absolutely would have given you a bunch of insights into German people at the time..

And you think it would give an accurate impression of the treatment of the Jewish population in Europe at the time?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: