Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The criticism is that it was fake.

Why was the experiment "fake", just because you say so? You claim is without evidence and without logic.

> Actual proper evidence for your theory that people automatically become evil when given power over others is in fact rather hard to come by.

Your "people automatically become evil" skips over the all important questions like: What percentage become evil? How evil? And most importantly: How do the numbers of those who succumb to evil and the severity of the evil inside them grow over time?

The fact is, evil spreads to near 100% of the people and tends to 100% destructiveness as time goes on.

> evidence... is hard to come by.

Might be hard for some but, for those who are serious about this topic, plenty of evidence is readily available:

* Christopher R. Browning, "Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland" (1992)

* Harald Welzer, Täter: Wie aus ganz normalen Menschen Massenmörder werden ("Perpetrators: How Ordinary People Become Mass Murderers," 2005)

* Jan T. Gross, "Neighbors: The Destruction of the Jewish Community in Jedwabne, Poland" (2001)

* Wendy Lower, "Hitler's Furies: German Women in the Nazi Killing Fields" (2013).

> Such people exist, yes, but plenty of counterexamples exist too.

In the light of what I said above, do you understand how meaningless this statement is?

 help



> Why was the experiment "fake", just because you say so? You claim is without evidence and without logic.

This is pretty much the majority opinion at this point, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment#Cri... for some references.

> The fact is, evil spreads to near 100% of the people and tends to 100% destructiveness as time goes on.

You're gonna need a lot more than a couple WWII pop sci books to make this claim. 100% is a lot! An obvious counterexample in the same theme is Oskar Schindler. I struggle to believe he was the only one who did good despite wielding terrible power over others.


> This is pretty much the majority opinion at this point, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment#Cri... for some references.

That link addresses the criticism of a very short list of people, nothing even close to a "majority opinion". Also, the critics do not question the fact of people turning evil, they list excuses like "they succumbed to peer pressure" or "they did what was expected of them"...

However, in the lack of active opposition, there's always peer pressure and somebody expecting it from you - those who first succumb to evil expect the others to follow. Your apologetics plays fast and loose with words - it's one of the factors contributing to good men doing nothing and aiding the triumph of evil.

> You're gonna need a lot more than a couple WWII pop sci books to make this claim.

There you go again with your ignorance, born out of prejudice. All of the books I cited are written by historians and psychologists and they treat precisely the psychological aspects of converting men to evil, there's no fiction in any of them, the fiction is only in your head.

In fact, there are a lot more cases to illustrate the fallibility of men, I could've started with the bible but there isn't enough space to list everything. here's a partial list. * Milgram experiment * 60 million dead Europeans in WW2, * the Japanese troops in SE Asia in WW2, * Iraqis during the Iraq war when the police apparatus was destroyed by the US. * The US side in the same war as reported by Assange * Vietnam on both sides * Chile during Pinochet, * Haiti, like forever, * Rwanda, * Irish famine, etc, etc.

> An obvious counterexample in the same theme is Oskar Schindler. I struggle to believe he was the only one who did good despite wielding terrible power over others.

First off, this is strawman, "near 100%" doesn't mean literally 100%, it admits exceptions that do not change the spread or the destructiveness of the result.

Second, but in the same vein, what specifically did Schindler do? Saved 1,200 ... out of 60 million. Changed nothing. Your folksy thinking doesn't understand the logic of the situation, even a volcano eruption spares a few within its reach but that doesn't prevent the general destruction.

To make the subject more concrete: Do you think that better supervision is unwarranted for the abuses described in the OP? That's the real issue here, talking about the infallible goodness of men and attacking the Stanford experiment can only be viewed in that context - as a defense of the abuses.

If you commented out of context because you were triggered by your personal dislike of the experiment, you displayed the exact kind of weakness that allows evil to prevail.


> To make the subject more concrete: Do you think that better supervision is unwarranted for the abuses described in the OP? That's the real issue here, talking about the infallible goodness of men and attacking the Stanford experiment can only be viewed in that context - as a defense of the abuses.

WTF. I'm flagging your comment, this attack is obscene and completely unwarranted.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: